Why I Ditched Positive-Only Dog Training: How to Choose the Best Budget-Friendly E-Collar Safely

My hands were still shaking ten minutes after it happened.

Max, my goofy, lovable rescue, sat panting at my feet, completely oblivious to the fact that he’d almost died.

We were at the park, and for months, I had been the perfect “positive-only” dog owner.

I had the high-value treats, the clicker, and a vocabulary of praise that would make a motivational speaker blush.

We’d practiced recall in the yard a thousand times.

But when Max saw a squirrel dart across the grass, his brain simply switched off.

My calls of “Max, come!” were just meaningless sounds swallowed by the open air.

He bolted, a blur of fur heading straight for a busy road.

It was only the screech of tires and a driver with lightning-fast reflexes that prevented the unthinkable.

In that moment of sheer terror, I realized a painful truth: love, patience, and a pocketful of chicken weren’t enough.

My communication had failed at the most critical moment possible.

I was a novice dog owner who had followed all the standard advice, and that advice had led to a heartbreaking, near-fatal failure.

I needed a better way to talk to my dog, especially when he couldn’t hear me.

That desperate search, full of guilt and confusion, led me to reconsider the most controversial tool in dog training: the e-collar.

This is the story of how I learned to see it not as a weapon, but as a lifeline.

The Problem: When “Good Dog” Training Isn’t Enough

My experience with Max isn’t unique.

Many dedicated dog owners find themselves in a similar bind.

They embrace the principles of LIMA (Least Intrusive, Minimally Aversive) training, which is rightly considered the gold standard for teaching new behaviors.¹

It’s a wonderful, humane way to build a foundation.

But the real world, with all its chaotic, unpredictable distractions, often exposes a gap in the “positive-only” approach.²

The Motivation Mismatch

The core of the issue lies in what trainers call “self-reinforcing behaviors”.³

For a dog with a high prey drive like Max, chasing a squirrel isn’t just fun; it’s an intensely powerful, instinctual reward.

In that moment, the environment is offering a jackpot far more valuable than the piece of dehydrated liver in my pocket.³

This isn’t a failure of the dog’s love for its owner or the owner’s effort; it’s a fundamental mismatch of motivation.

When a dog is barking at another dog, chasing a cat, or jumping on a visitor, the act itself is often more rewarding than any treat we can offer as an alternative.³

The Management vs. Training Gap

Owners struggling with these issues often hear advice centered on management.

For example, if your dog barks at people from the car, crate them.

If your dog pulls on the leash, avoid busy areas.⁵

Management is a crucial first step—it prevents the dog from rehearsing unwanted behaviors.

However, many owners, myself included, find themselves stuck in a “management wheel.” We can prevent the problem, but we can’t seem to solve it.

A dog crated in the car isn’t learning

not to bark at strangers; it’s simply being prevented from doing so.⁵

This creates a frustrating gap between keeping a dog safe and giving a dog freedom.

It’s this very gap that pushes responsible owners to look for a tool that can bridge the divide between management and true, reliable training.

The Epiphany: It’s Not a Shock, It’s a Tap on the Shoulder

My initial research into e-collars was filled with shame.

The term “shock collar” conjured images of cruelty and pain, and I felt like a failure for even considering it.

The internet is a battlefield of opinions, with one side screaming “abuse” and the other promising “miracles.” The breakthrough for me—my epiphany—came when I found a simple analogy that reframed the entire concept.

A modern, high-quality e-collar is not an electric chair.

It’s a tap on the shoulder from across the park.⁶

Think about it.

When your dog is right next to you, you communicate through touch all the time.

A gentle tug on the leash is a tactile cue.⁸

This is, in fact, a dog’s primary language.⁹

Humans are verbal; dogs are physical.

The e-collar is simply an extension of that tactile language, a silent, haptic pager that allows you to communicate that same light touch when the leash is gone.

This reframing shifts the entire mental model from punishment to communication.

The goal isn’t to hurt the dog; it’s to get their attention through the noise of distraction so they can listen to the command they already know.

The “pressure” from a low-level e-collar is often misunderstood.

It’s not about intimidation.

It’s more like the persistent “dinging” of a seatbelt alarm in a car—an annoying but harmless prompt that you, the driver, have complete control over.

The moment you perform the correct action (buckling up), the annoying sound stops.⁹

The entire process of humane e-collar conditioning is about teaching the dog that they have the power to turn off that gentle, annoying “tap” simply by complying with a request.

Navigating the Noise: Why Is Everyone Yelling About E-Collars?

To make an informed decision, you have to understand the landscape of the controversy.

The debate is so heated because, in many ways, the two sides are arguing about completely different things.

The Case Against

Opponents of e-collars raise legitimate and important concerns.

They point to the very real risks of physical and psychological harm, including skin burns, increased anxiety, aggression, and a phenomenon known as “learned helplessness,” where a dog becomes withdrawn and depressed from being unable to escape punishment.¹⁰

These critics often highlight how a dog might associate the pain of a shock not with its own action, but with something else in the environment—like you, or a child, or another dog—leading to a catastrophic breakdown of trust and the creation of new fears.¹³

These arguments are valid and should be taken seriously, as they often stem from experiences with outdated technology or improper, abusive use.

The Case For (The Balanced View)

Modern, balanced trainers who advocate for the tool present a different perspective.

They argue that an e-collar is just that—a tool.

A hammer can build a house or be used as a weapon; the outcome depends entirely on the user.¹⁵

From this viewpoint, the e-collar serves a specific purpose: to provide a clear, effective “no” for dangerous or highly self-reinforcing behaviors when positive methods alone are insufficient.³

The goal is not to inflict pain, but to achieve clear communication that leads to reliability, safety, and ultimately, the holy grail for many dog owners: true off-leash freedom.⁴

The heart of the controversy is a generational technology divide.

Many opponents are, understandably, picturing the crude “shock boxes” of the past, which had only a few brutally high settings.¹⁵

Proponents, however, are talking about modern, technologically advanced devices with 100 or more finely-tuned levels of stimulation, safety locks, and different types of sensation.¹⁵

The term “shock collar” is a relic that carries the baggage of old, inhumane technology.

The conversation can’t move forward until we acknowledge that the tool itself has evolved dramatically.

The Anatomy of a “Humane” E-Collar: What Your Money Really Buys

Moving from philosophy to engineering, the difference between a humane communication tool and a cheap punishment device comes down to a few critical features.

Understanding these will help you see why a higher price often translates directly to greater safety and fairness for your dog.

Key Features Explained

• Wide Range of Stimulation Levels (100+): This is the single most important feature. The goal of humane conditioning is to find the lowest possible level your dog can perceive—often just an ear twitch or a curious glance.¹⁹ This requires incredible nuance. A collar with only 10 levels is like trying to tune a radio with a sledgehammer; a collar with 100+ levels is like having a precision dial.
• “Blunt Pulse” vs. “Sharp Pulse” Stimulation: This is a key technological difference. High-quality brands like Educator use “blunt” or “wide pulse” stimulation, which feels more like a therapeutic muscle contraction from a TENS unit. Cheaper collars often use “sharp pulse” stimulation, which feels like a startling static shock.¹⁹ The former communicates, the latter frightens.
• Safety Features: Look for a “Lock and Set” feature that prevents you from accidentally turning the dial and over-stimulating your dog.¹⁹ A waterproof or water-resistant design is crucial for reliability in all weather, and a clear LCD display is essential for knowing your settings at a glance, day or night.¹⁹
• Consistency: This is paramount. A quality collar delivers the exact same stimulation at level 12 every single time. Inconsistent output from a cheap collar makes it impossible for a dog to learn the pattern, which is unfair and confusing.²³

Table 1: The E-Collar Quality Spectrum: Budget vs. Professional-Grade

Feature	Typical Budget Collar (<$75)	Professional-Grade Collar ($150+)
Stimulation Levels	1-16 or 1-99, often with large jumps between levels	100+, allowing for very fine, nuanced adjustments 19
Stimulation Type	“Sharp pulse” static shock; often described as painful even at low levels 24	“Blunt pulse” muscle stimulation; described as a gentle “tap” or TENS-like sensation 19
Consistency	Notoriously inconsistent; stimulation can vary or fail entirely 23	Medically consistent and reliable output every time 19
Safety Features	Minimal; may lack a lock feature, leading to accidental over-stimulation 26	Lock-and-Set dials, boost functions, waterproof design, clear displays 19
Waterproofing	Often just “water-resistant”; prone to failure in wet conditions 27	Fully waterproof and submersible, ensuring reliability 19
Battery Life	Often poor and unreliable, with frequent complaints of not holding a charge 25	Long-lasting, quick-charge batteries designed for field use 29
Warranty	Limited or non-existent	Often 2-year or lifetime warranties, with strong customer support 19

The Golden Rules: A Step-by-Step Guide to Humane E-Collar Conditioning

Buying the right tool is only half the battle.

Using it correctly and humanely is everything.

The following steps, synthesized from the methods of respected balanced trainers, will guide you in teaching your dog to understand the e-collar as a clear communication device, not a source of fear.³¹

Step 1: Acclimation (The “Dead Collar” Phase)

For at least one week, have your dog wear the e-collar without ever turning it on.

Put it on before meals, before walks, before playtime—all the good things.³³

The goal is to create a positive or neutral association with the collar itself.

This prevents your dog from becoming “collar-wise,” where they only behave when the e-collar is on.

Step 2: Finding the “Working Level”

In a quiet, distraction-free environment like your living room, begin with the collar set to level 1.

Tap the continuous stimulation button and watch your dog closely.

Are they twitching an ear? Turning their head? Do they look around as if a fly just landed on them? You are looking for the lowest possible level that elicits a subtle, curious reaction, not a yelp or a sign of pain.³²

This is your dog’s “working level.” Most humans can’t even feel it on their hand.

Step 3: Layering & Leash Pressure (Teaching the Language)

This is where you teach the dog how to turn the stimulation off.

Start with a command your dog knows well, like “Come.”

1. Have your dog on a leash.
2. Say your command, “Come.”
3. Simultaneously, press and hold the continuous stimulation button at their working level and apply gentle, steady pressure on the leash to guide them toward you.
4. The instant your dog starts moving toward you, release the e-collar button and the leash pressure at the same time.
5. When they reach you, give them a high-value reward (treat, toy, praise) and celebrate.³¹

Through repetition, the dog learns: “That tapping sensation means I need to listen.

When I do what is asked, the tapping stops and I get a reward.” They are in complete control.

Step 4: Proofing and Fading

Once your dog is reliable in the house, you can gradually move to environments with more distractions, like the backyard, and then a quiet park.

You slowly “fade” the leash, letting it drag on the ground before removing it entirely.

Always set your dog up for success by starting with low distractions and working your way up.

The Cardinal Rules of Humane Use

• NEVER correct out of anger or frustration. The e-collar is a communication tool, not an outlet for your emotions.³³
• ONLY correct for a known command that your dog is willfully ignoring. It is unfair to correct a dog for not doing something it hasn’t been taught.
• ALWAYS follow a correction with an opportunity for the dog to comply and earn a reward. This reinforces that the communication is not punitive, but instructional.

The “Budget” Trap: Why the Cheapest Collar Can Be the Most Expensive Mistake

This brings us back to the original question: finding the best budget e-collar.

After my journey, I’ve come to believe that when it comes to this specific tool, “budget” and “safe” are often at odds.

An unreliable tool is an unfair and therefore unethical tool.

Effective training is built on a foundation of consistency.³⁶

If a dog receives a correction at level 5 one time, but the next time the battery is dead or the stimulation is inconsistent, the dog cannot learn the pattern.

This randomness doesn’t teach; it creates confusion, anxiety, and stress—the very psychological harms that opponents rightfully warn about.¹¹

User reviews of popular budget brands are filled with these red flags:

• Bousnic: Users frequently report that even the lowest settings are uncomfortably strong and “painful,” making nuanced, low-level conditioning impossible.²⁴
• Premier Pet: This brand is plagued by complaints of abysmal battery life and the collar simply malfunctioning or failing to work when needed.²⁵
• PATPET: While often seen as a better budget option, reviews still mention issues with the shock function failing over time, undermining the reliability needed for fair training.³⁸

Investing in a cheap, unreliable collar isn’t just a financial risk; it’s an ethical one.

It sets both you and your dog up for a frustrating and potentially harmful experience.

The cheapest collar can be the most expensive mistake if it damages your dog’s trust and well-being.

My Recommendations: The Best Value E-Collars for Responsible Owners

Instead of “cheapest,” I encourage you to think in terms of “best value”—the lowest price point for a tool that is safe, reliable, and humane.

Tier 1: The Professional Standard

• Educator ET-300 Mini (~$200): This is the gold standard for a reason.³⁹ It features the “blunt pulse” stimulation, 100 levels, a lock-and-set dial, and an ergonomic “stopwatch” design that is easy to use without looking.¹⁹ It’s the “buy once, cry once” option that professional trainers trust.

Tier 2: The Reliable Workhorses

• SportDOG 425X (~$150-$180): A durable, reliable collar built for field use.⁴² It has 21 levels of stimulation, is fully waterproof, and is known for its ruggedness.²⁹ While it has fewer levels than the Educator, it’s a solid, dependable choice.
• DT Systems DD700 (~$150-$170): Another excellent workhorse, the DD700 offers 10 levels, a “Jump” feature to pre-program a higher correction, and a user-friendly remote.²⁸ It’s a high-quality, reliable tool for its price point.

Tier 3: The Cautious Entry-Level Option

• PATPET P650 (~$50-$65): This is the only sub-$100 collar I can mention with serious caveats.⁴⁶ It has decent features for the price, including 16 levels and waterproofing.⁴⁸ However, its reliability is a step down from the professional-grade brands. This should only be considered if Tier 2 is absolutely out of reach, and it must be used with extra diligence to ensure it’s functioning consistently.

Table 2: Recommended E-Collar Models: A Comparative Review

Model	Price Range	Stimulation Levels	Key Features	Best For	Key Drawback
Educator ET-300 Mini	$199 – $240 39	100 Levels + Boost	Blunt Pulse Stimulation, Lock & Set Dial, Ergonomic Remote 19	Owners seeking the most humane, nuanced, and reliable tool, especially for sensitive dogs.	Highest initial cost.
SportDOG 425X	$150 – $180 42	21 Levels	DryTek Waterproofing, 500-yard range, very durable build 29	Hunting and field work; owners needing a rugged, all-weather workhorse.	Fewer stimulation levels; may be too strong for very sensitive dogs.23
DT Systems DD700	$150 – $170 28	10 Levels + Jump	MAXX-Range 360 antenna, Vibration Assist, user-friendly remote 28	Owners who want a simple, intuitive remote and a reliable mid-range option.	Fewer base levels; some users report issues with contact points on long-haired dogs.45
PATPET P650	$50 – $65 46	16 Levels	IPX7 Waterproof, dual-channel for two dogs, very low price 48	Owners on a strict budget who understand and accept the lower reliability.	Less consistent performance and durability compared to higher-tier models.38

Know the Law: A Quick Guide to E-Collar Legality

Finally, before you purchase any device, it is your responsibility to know your local laws.

The legality of e-collars varies significantly by country and even by state or province.

• USA: Generally legal at the federal level, though some states like New York have considered bans.⁵⁵
• United Kingdom: Banned in Wales since 2010. A ban is set to take effect in England in early 2024.⁵⁷
• Australia: A patchwork of state laws. Banned in New South Wales, South Australia, and ACT, but regulated use is permitted in others like Queensland and Victoria.⁵⁹
• Canada: Banned in the province of Quebec, but generally permitted elsewhere.⁶²
• New Zealand: While not banned, major veterinary and training organizations strongly oppose their use due to welfare concerns.⁶⁴

Laws are constantly evolving.

Always check your current local and state/provincial regulations before purchasing or using an e-collar.

Conclusion: The Path to Off-Leash Freedom

Today, Max and I hike in the mountains off-leash.

His recall is immediate and happy.

The e-collar, which he wears with the same excitement as his leash, is now a tool I rarely have to use.

It’s a seatbelt—there for safety, but not part of the everyday driving experience.

It gave me a way to have a clear conversation with him in moments of high distraction, and that clear communication built a new level of trust I never thought possible after that terrifying day at the park.

An e-collar is not a shortcut or a replacement for good training.

It is a powerful communication tool that, when chosen with care and used with compassion, can bridge the gap where other methods sometimes fall short.

It empowers you to be the clear, confident leader your dog needs, and in return, it gives your dog the greatest gift of all: the safety to enjoy a life of freedom.

The best “budget” choice is not the cheapest one, but the one that protects your dog, your relationship, and your peace of mind.

Works cited

1. Balanced Dog Training vs. Positive Reinforcement | PetMD, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petmd.com/dog/training/balanced-dog-training-vs-positive-reinforcement
2. Positive reinforcement doesn’t work for every dog, and other assertions., accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.sit-pretty.ca/blog/positive-reinforcement-doesnt-work-for-every-dog-and-other-assertions
3. POSITIVE ONLY TRAINING FLAWS – Wagging Rights Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.waggingrightsdogtraining.com/positive-only-training-flaws
4. How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Shock Collar — Roots K9 | Norman Oklahoma Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.rootsk9.com/blog/2018/12/18/how-i-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-the-shock-collar
5. Positive Reinforcement can’t work in all situations. : r/reactivedogs – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/reactivedogs/comments/1eoxmqd/positive_reinforcement_cant_work_in_all_situations/
6. What are some simple analogies you use to explain dog training concepts to clients?, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/3035kz/what_are_some_simple_analogies_you_use_to_explain/
7. Amazing Analogies To Support Your Dog – Your Happy Dog Coach, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.yourhappydogcoach.ca/amazing-analogies/
8. How to Communicate with Your Dog During Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.gundogmag.com/editorial/communicate-dog-during-training/529372
9. Aversive Tools in Dog Training: What You Need to Understand – Long Haul Trekkers, accessed August 11, 2025, https://longhaultrekkers.com/aversive-tools-in-dog-training/
10. Why Shock Collars Hurt Dogs and Better Training Methods – Canine …, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.caninecampus.us/why-shock-collars-hurt-dogs-and-better-training-methods
11. The Shocking Truth About Shock Collars – Three Oaks Animal Behavior Counseling, accessed August 11, 2025, https://animalbehaviorok.com/shocking-truth-about-shock-collars/
12. Why E-Collar Dog Training Is Not Recommended – Whole Dog Journal, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/training/why-e-collar-dog-training-is-not-recommended/
13. Shock Collars: Barbaric, Ineffective, and Unacceptable – NAVTA, accessed August 11, 2025, https://navta.net/head-to-tail-w-steve-dale/shock-collars-barbaric-ineffective-and-unacceptable/
14. 5 Reasons not to use a shock collar – BC SPCA, accessed August 11, 2025, https://spca.bc.ca/ways-to-help/take-action/animals-in-the-home/the-shocking-truth-about-electronic-collars/5-reasons-not-to-use-a-shock-collar/
15. The Most Controversial Tool in Dog Training – Pack Leader Dogs, accessed August 11, 2025, https://packleaderdogs.com/the-most-controversial-tool-in-dog-training/
16. E-Collars in Dog Training: The Controversy & Practice, accessed August 11, 2025, https://chilloutdogtraining.com/e-collars/e-collars-in-dog-training/
17. Are E-collars Cruel? The TRUTH behind the controversy – YouTube, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWE0Dqe87pw&pp=0gcJCfwAo7VqN5tD
18. I Love My E-collar and So Does My Dog! | Dog Training Blog – Robin MacFarlane, accessed August 11, 2025, https://robinmacfarlane.com/i-love-my-e-collar-and-so-does-my-dog/
19. About E Collar Technologies – Educator Collars, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.educatorcollars.com/about-ecollar-technologies
20. Getting Started with E-Collar Training – Chicago Dog Trainer, accessed August 11, 2025, https://chicagodogtrainer.com/about/blog/164-ecollar-training.html
21. Exploring the Mini Educator: A Comprehensive Guide to E-Collar Technologies, accessed August 11, 2025, https://jacksonk9training.com/exploring-the-mini-educator-a-comprehensive-guide-to-e-collar-technologies/
22. The Shock Collar (Podcast Episode 50) | Happy Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://happydogtraining.info/podcast/shock-collar/
23. E collar help!? Tried 3 different ones so far : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/xhul76/e_collar_help_tried_3_different_ones_so_far/
24. Bousnic v Dogtra v Mini Educator : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/197hmi1/bousnic_v_dogtra_v_mini_educator/
25. Customer reviews for Premier Pet 300 Yard Remote Trainer, 3 Correction Modes, Rechargeable, Waterproof, Gray – Walmart, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.walmart.com/reviews/product/373769494
26. Premier Pet 300 Yard Remote Trainer – 3 Correction Modes – Rechargeable & Waterproof Collar – PetSmart, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petsmart.com/dog/training-and-behavior/training-and-behavior-accessories/premier-pet-300-yard-remote-trainer—3-correction-modes—rechargeable-and-waterproof-collar-80226.html
27. 300 Yard Trainer – Premier Pet, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.premierpet.com/300-yard-remote-trainer/
28. DOG Director 700 Compact e collar (DD700) – DT Systems, accessed August 11, 2025, https://dtsystems.com/products/dd700
29. SportDOG 425 Expert Review | SportDOG 425X vs.425Xs – Technobark, accessed August 11, 2025, https://technobark.com/sportdog-425-review/
30. Premier Pet 300 Yard Remote Adjustable Trainer – Black – Target, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.target.com/p/premier-pet-300-yard-remote-adjustable-trainer-black/-/A-82211069
31. Larry Krohn – e collar training : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/jm5f1w/larry_krohn_e_collar_training/
32. Introducing E-Collar | When and How to Use an E Collar for Training – Rob’s Dogs, accessed August 11, 2025, https://robsdogs.com/e-collar-education/
33. Feeling nervous! Your e-collar success stories, please! : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/cc2cbw/feeling_nervous_your_ecollar_success_stories/
34. What to Look for in a Balanced Dog Trainer Using E-Collars? : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/1ir3nuq/what_to_look_for_in_a_balanced_dog_trainer_using/
35. A Comprehensive Guide to E Collar Training for Dogs – Pet Control HQ, accessed August 11, 2025, https://petcontrolhq.com/blogs/news/e-collar-training-for-dogs
36. Position Statement: Use of Electronic Stimulation (Shock) Collars in Training Dogs, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.apdtnz.org.nz/position-statement-use-of-electronic-stimulation-shock-collars-in-training-dogs
37. Product Reviews for BOUSNIC Remote Waterproof Dog Training Collar, 3300-ft – Chewy, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.chewy.com/bousnic-remote-waterproof-dog/product-reviews/762558
38. Product Reviews for PATPET P650 Anti-Bark & Remote Dog Training Collar – Chewy.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.chewy.com/patpet-p650-anti-bark-remote-dog/product-reviews/297928
39. Educator ET-300 Mini | E Collar Technologies – Educator Collars, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.educatorcollars.com/educator-et-300-mini.html
40. Mini Educator ET-300 Remote Dog Training Collar ZEN by E-Collar Technologies – PetsTEK, accessed August 11, 2025, https://petstek.com/products/mini-educator-et-300-remote-dog-training-collar-zen-by-e-collar-technologies
41. E-Collar Technologies ET-300 / ET-302 Mini Remote Dog Training Collar | K9 Electronics, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.k9electronics.com/e-collar-technologies-mini-educator-et-300.html
42. FieldTrainer® – Introduce Your Dog To In-The-Field Training – SportDOG, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.sportdog.com/fieldtrainer
43. SportDOG 425X FieldTrainer® – Remote Dog Training Collar – Sporting Dog Pro, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.sportingdogpro.com/dog-training-collars/family-dogs/sportdog-field-trainer-425x
44. SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainer – Rechargeable Dog Tra – Petsense, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petsense.com/products/sportdog-brand-fieldtrainer-425x-remote-trainer-rechargeable-dog-training-collar-with-shock-vibrate-and-tone-500-yard-range-sd-425x
45. DT Systems DD700 D.O.G. Director Remote Training Collar – Gun Dog Supply, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.gundogsupply.com/dt-systems-dd700.html
46. PATPET P650 Anti-Bark & Remote Dog Training Collar, White, 2 count – Chewy.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.chewy.com/patpet-p650-anti-bark-remote-dog/dp/297928
47. 6 Series – PATPET, accessed August 11, 2025, https://patpet.com/collections/6-series
48. Comprehensive Review of the Patpet P650 Dog Training Collar – Yokum Gear, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.yokumgear.com/blogs/news/patpet-p650
49. ET-300 Mini Educator Ecollar – The Everyday Trainer Shop, accessed August 11, 2025, https://shop.theeverydaytrainer.com/products/et-300-mini-educator
50. SportDOG® Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainer – 500 Yard – Static/Vibrate/Tone Correction – PetSmart, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petsmart.com/dog/training-and-behavior/training-and-behavior-accessories/sportdog-brand-fieldtrainer-425x-remote-trainer—500-yard—staticvibratetone-correction-57063.html
51. FieldTrainer® 425x – Store | SportDOG, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.sportdog.com/p/fieldtrainer-425x/SD-425X
52. DT Systems DD700 – Dog and Hunt Supply, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.dogandhunt.com/collections/bark-collars/products/dt-systems-dd700
53. DT Systems D.O.G. Director 700 Training Collar – Walmart.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.walmart.com/ip/DT-Systems-D-O-G-Director-700-Training-Collar/2919861594
54. PATPET P650 1000ft Waterproof Dog Training Safe Shock Collar with Remote ,Vibrate Zap Tone Functions for Small Medium Large Dogs (15-120lbs) – Walmart, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.walmart.com/ip/PATPET-P650-1000ft-Waterproof-Dog-Training-Safe-Shock-Collar-with-Remote-Vibrate-Zap-Tone-Functions-for-Small-Medium-Large-Dogs-15-120lbs/882215149
55. www.dogster.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/are-shock-collars-illegal#:~:text=Shock%20collars%20are%20legal%20in,collars%20is%20widely%20considered%20substandard.
56. Where are E-Collars Banned? – Dog Training in Fort Collins, Colorado – One of the Pack, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.oneofthepackco.com/pack-talk/where-are-e-collars-banned
57. Ban electric shock collars | The Kennel Club, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.thekennelclub.org.uk/about-us/campaigns/electric-shock-collars/
58. England Moves to Ban Electric Shock Collars for Dogs | Psychology Today, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/fellow-creatures/202304/england-moves-to-ban-electric-shock-collars-for-dogs
59. Are Dog Shock Collars Allowed in Australia? A Quick Guide, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.dogfriendlyco.com/blogs/articles/are-dog-shock-collars-allowed-in-australia
60. Is the use of electronic dog collars legal? – RSPCA Knowledgebase, accessed August 11, 2025, https://kb.rspca.org.au/knowledge-base/is-the-use-of-electronic-dog-collars-legal/
61. SHOCK COLLARS Legal or Illegal in Australia? E-Collars & Bark Collars – BARKAHOLICS®, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.shockcollars.com.au/pages/legal-info
62. Quebec Bans Prong and Shock Collars for Pets – Pet Camp, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petcamp.com/blog/quebec-bans-prong-shock-collars-for-pets/
63. ban shock collars.ca, accessed August 11, 2025, https://banshockcollars.ca/
64. Policy: Behaviour modifying collar use on dogs – New Zealand Veterinary Association, accessed August 11, 2025, https://nzva.org.nz/positions-advocacy/position-statements/collars/
65. nzva.org.nz, accessed August 11, 2025, https://nzva.org.nz/positions-advocacy/position-statements/collars/#:~:text=The%20NZVA%20does%20not%20support,and%20mental%20health%20of%20dogs.