How I Stopped Failing My Dog and Learned to Grow Together – The Books That Changed Everything

The Heartbreak of a Broken Machine

The day I brought Max home, I had a plan.

It was a good plan, or so I thought, pieced together from a lifetime of cultural osmosis, popular TV shows, and well-meaning advice.

Max was a rescue, a lanky mix of everything with eyes that held a universe of anxiety.

He was smart, sensitive, and desperately in need of structure.

My plan was to give it to him.

I was going to be the “pack leader.” I was going to be firm, fair, and in charge.

I was going to “fix” him.

I followed the playbook to the letter.

Walks were structured with a short leash, and I’d give a sharp “leash pop” if he pulled.

I made him wait for food, went through doorways first, and claimed the best spots on the couch as my own.

I was asserting my “alpha” status, just like the books and shows had told me to.

I believed I was building a relationship based on respect.

In reality, I was laying the groundwork for heartbreak.

Max’s biggest “issue” was what trainers call leash reactivity.

The sight of another dog would send him into a frenzy of barking, lunging, and snarling.

My playbook told me this was a challenge to my leadership.

So, I doubled down.

My leash corrections became sharper, my “No!” more forceful.

I was trying to suppress the behavior, to force the machine into compliance.

The breaking point came on a crisp autumn afternoon in the park.

We saw another dog, a placid-looking Golden Retriever, approaching from a distance.

I tensed, shortening the leash until my knuckles were white.

“Be good,” I muttered, a command that was more of a prayer.

Max saw the dog, and the familiar tension shot through his body like a current.

As the dog drew closer, Max exploded.

It was worse than ever before—a terrifying, guttural display that seemed to come from a place of pure panic.

He lunged so hard he pulled me off balance.

The other owner, a woman with a kind face now etched with fear, quickly pulled her dog away.

I stood there, heart pounding, utterly mortified.

But the shame was nothing compared to the look on Max’s face.

He wasn’t defiant.

He wasn’t trying to be “dominant.” He was trembling, his eyes wide with a terror I had only amplified.

In my quest to be his leader, I had become his biggest source of fear.

The bond I thought I was building was a fragile illusion, and it had just shattered.

Looking at my frightened, confused dog, a question bloomed in the wreckage of my confidence, a question that would change everything for both of us: “What if everything I think I know about dogs is wrong?”

The Mechanic’s Mindset: Why My Old Toolkit Was Doomed to Fail

That question forced me to examine the very foundation of my approach.

I realized I had been operating under what I now call the “Mechanic’s Mindset.” I saw my dog as a machine, a beautiful but flawed piece of engineering.

When a part was “broken”—like his reaction to other dogs—my job was to use tools and force to correct it.

It was a mindset focused on suppression, control, and immediate compliance.

It was about working on the dog, not with him.

And as I discovered, this entire approach is built on a blueprint that is scientifically flawed and historically misguided.

The Historical Roots of the Mechanic’s Toolkit

The forceful, compliance-first methods that many of us absorb as “traditional” dog training have a specific origin.

They didn’t emerge from a deep understanding of the canine-human bond; they were forged for war and police work in the early-to-mid 20th century.¹

Figures like Colonel Konrad Most, who wrote a manual for training military and police service dogs, and William Koehler, whose methods became mainstream after WWII, were pioneers in a field that demanded absolute obedience under extreme conditions.²

Their techniques, often involving heavy-handed corrections and negative reinforcement, were designed to create soldiers, not companions.

The goal was simple: “do it, or else”.¹

While these methods were influential, they are now largely viewed as unnecessarily harsh and reliant on coercion.²

Yet, their legacy persists, forming the chassis of the Mechanic’s Mindset.

The Flawed Blueprint: Dominance and “Pack Theory”

Layered on top of this history of coercion is a pervasive and deeply flawed theory: the idea of the “alpha” and the dominance-based pack hierarchy.

This theory, which has been popularized to an incredible degree, suggests that dogs are in a constant struggle for status and that humans must establish themselves as the “alpha” or “pack leader” to prevent their dogs from taking over.

This entire concept is largely based on outdated and misinterpreted studies of captive wolves from the 1940s—groups of unrelated animals forced to live together, which resulted in high levels of conflict.¹

Modern research on wolves in their natural habitat reveals a completely different picture: wolf packs function like human families, with the parents guiding their offspring, not a tyrannical “alpha” physically dominating subordinates.³

The very scientists who first proposed the “alpha” theory have since worked to debunk it, but the myth remains stubbornly lodged in the public consciousness.⁴

This debunked theory is the central operating system for some of the most popular training philosophies of the last few decades:

• Cesar Millan: Through his wildly popular show, Dog Whisperer, Millan brought “pack leader” theory into millions of homes.⁵ His mantra of “exercise, discipline, affection—in that order” and his focus on projecting “calm-assertive energy” became gospel for many struggling owners, myself included.⁷ However, his methods are not based on modern behavioral science and have been widely criticized by veterinary and training organizations.³ Techniques like the “alpha roll,” physical jabs, and the use of tools that cause discomfort rely on punishment and a technique called “flooding,” where a dog is exposed to a trigger at full intensity until it essentially shuts down.¹⁰ The constant “Don’t Try This At Home” disclaimers on his shows are a significant red flag, acknowledging the inherent risks of these confrontational methods.⁹ The International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants (IAABC) and the Association of Professional Dog Trainers (APDT) have issued statements directly refuting dominance theory, highlighting that it can damage the human-animal bond and often leads to the use of punishment.⁴
• The Monks of New Skete: Offering a more spiritual and seemingly compassionate alternative, the Monks’ books, like The Art of Raising a Puppy, are also fundamentally rooted in the same dominance framework.¹¹ They advocate for owners to become “benevolent pack leaders” and, while they speak of love and respect, they also endorse physical corrections like the “scruff shake” as a last resort.¹³ This presents a softer, more palatable version of the Mechanic’s Mindset, but it’s still about establishing a hierarchy through physical assertion, a humane form of dominance, rather than building a partnership based on modern behavioral science.¹²

The Modern Mechanic’s Toolkit: The “Balanced” Training Fallacy

The Mechanic’s Mindset has evolved.

Today, its most common and seductive form is “balanced” training.

Proponents present it as a pragmatic, middle-of-the-road approach that uses both rewards (positive reinforcement) and corrections (punishment).¹⁵

It sounds reasonable on the surface—”use what works,” “the best of both worlds.”

The problem lies in what “corrections” usually entail.

The balanced trainer’s toolkit often includes aversive equipment like prong collars, choke chains, and shock collars (often rebranded as “e-collars” or “stim-collars”).¹⁷

These tools are designed to function through positive punishment (adding an unpleasant sensation to stop a behavior) or negative reinforcement (the unpleasant sensation stops when the dog complies).

While advocates claim these tools provide “clear communication,” leading professional organizations strongly disagree.¹⁶

The APDT, in its official standards of practice, explicitly states that its members must not use tools like choke, prong, or shock collars, or any technique “designed to intentionally cause fear, pain, or startle”.¹⁹

Their position is that such methods are not only inhumane but also carry significant risks, including increased fear, anxiety, and aggression—the very things I was seeing in Max.¹⁷

The “balanced” approach, I came to understand, was still just mechanics.

It might suppress a behavior temporarily, but it does nothing to change the underlying emotion driving it.

A dog that stops lunging because it fears the pain of a prong collar hasn’t learned to be calm; it has only learned to fear the consequence of expressing its fear.

This was the dead end I had reached.

My toolkit was not just ineffective; it was actively harming the very relationship I was trying to build.

The Gardener’s Epiphany: A New Way of Seeing

Standing in that park, with a terrified dog at the end of my leash, I finally let go of the Mechanic’s Mindset.

The epiphany that followed wasn’t a complex scientific formula; it was a simple, profound shift in perspective.

I looked at Max, trembling and overwhelmed, and thought, “He isn’t a broken car I need to fix.

He’s a garden I need to cultivate.”

That one change in metaphor unlocked everything.

It transformed my entire understanding of my role and my relationship with my dog.

The “Gardening vs. Mechanics” Analogy Explained

This new paradigm became my guiding light.

Here’s how I see it:

• Mechanics diagnose a single, isolated problem—a faulty alternator, a squeaky belt. They use force and specific tools to fix or replace that one part. Their goal is immediate compliance and a return to function. They work on the machine from the outside.
• Gardeners, on the other hand, understand that a plant is part of a complex ecosystem. A wilting leaf isn’t the problem; it’s a symptom. A good gardener doesn’t try to “fix” the leaf by yanking on it or painting it green. Instead, they look at the whole system. Is the soil healthy? Is there enough sunlight? Is it getting the right amount of water? Is it being crowded by weeds? A gardener works to create the conditions for the plant to thrive on its own. Their goal is long-term health, resilience, and vitality. They work with the garden from the inside out.

This was the shift I needed.

Max’s lunging and barking wasn’t a “broken” part.

It was a symptom of an unhealthy ecosystem—one filled with fear, anxiety, and a lack of trust in his environment and, most painfully, in me.

My job wasn’t to punish the symptom; it was to cultivate a healthier garden where that symptom no longer needed to exist.

The Gardener’s Guiding Principles: The Science of Growth

Embracing the Gardener’s Mindset meant I needed a new set of tools and principles, ones based not on force and suppression, but on science and cultivation.

I found them in the world of modern, humane dog training.

The Ethical Soil: LIMA (Least Intrusive, Minimally Aversive)

The first and most important principle for any gardener is “First, do no harm.” In the world of modern animal training, this is codified in the principle of LIMA: Least Intrusive, Minimally Aversive.²⁰

Championed by professional bodies like the APDT and the IAABC, LIMA is an ethical framework that guides a trainer’s decisions.²²

It’s often visualized as the “Humane Hierarchy,” a concept developed by Dr. Susan Friedman, a psychology professor who applied the principles of Applied Behavior Analysis to animals.²⁴

The hierarchy ranks training interventions from least to most intrusive:

1. Health, Nutrition, and Physical Environment: Is the dog healthy? Is its environment safe and enriching?
2. Antecedent Arrangement: Can we manage the environment to prevent the problem behavior from occurring in the first place?
3. Positive Reinforcement (R+): This is the first-line strategy for teaching new behaviors.
4. Differential Reinforcement of Alternative Behaviors: Reinforcing a different, more appropriate behavior.
5. Negative Punishment, Negative Reinforcement, Extinction: More intrusive methods that involve removing something good or applying/removing something unpleasant.
6. Positive Punishment (P+): The most intrusive method, which involves adding something unpleasant to stop a behavior. This is the last resort.

A true LIMA practitioner doesn’t just have all these tools in their toolbox and pick whichever they want.

They start at the bottom of the hierarchy and only move up if a less intrusive method has been competently tried and failed.²⁴

This is the fundamental difference between a Gardener and a “balanced” Mechanic.

The Gardener’s first instinct is to nurture and reinforce, not to correct and punish.

The Sunlight and Water: Operant and Classical Conditioning

With LIMA as the ethical soil, the Gardener uses two powerful scientific principles to help the garden grow.

These concepts, largely developed by the psychologist B.F.

Skinner, explain how all animals learn.¹

• Operant Conditioning (The Fertilizer): This is about how consequences influence voluntary behavior. The most important tool here is Positive Reinforcement (R+). This is the Gardener’s nutrient-rich fertilizer. When you add something the dog wants (a high-value treat, praise, a favorite toy) immediately after a behavior, you increase the likelihood that the behavior will happen again.¹⁷ Instead of saying “Don’t jump,” you use R+ to teach and grow a beautiful “Sit.” This process builds a relationship based on cooperation, enthusiasm, and trust. The dog learns that good things happen when they engage with you.
• Classical Conditioning (The Weather): This is about changing involuntary, emotional responses. It’s about changing the emotional weather. For Max, the sight of another dog was a dark storm cloud that produced an automatic feeling of fear. Through classical conditioning, I could change that association. By pairing the appearance of the storm cloud (another dog at a safe distance) with a shower of sunshine (incredibly delicious treats like chicken or cheese), I could change his emotional forecast.²⁷ Over time, the sight of another dog began to predict something wonderful, and his emotional response shifted from fear to happy anticipation. This is the most powerful tool for “weeding” the garden of fear and anxiety.

The Gardener’s Goal: From Obedience to Partnership

Adopting the Gardener’s Mindset completely reframed my goal.

I was no longer trying to manufacture an obedient machine that would comply with my commands.

I was trying to cultivate a resilient, confident, and joyful partner.

My job was to understand his needs, manage his environment wisely, and use the science of learning to help him navigate a world that often felt scary.

The goal wasn’t blind obedience; it was a thriving partnership.

This new perspective gave me hope, and it gave me a path forward.

All I needed now was a library of guidebooks.

The Gardener’s Library: Essential Books for a Thriving Partnership

My journey from a frustrated Mechanic to a hopeful Gardener was guided by books.

Not just any books, but a curated collection that, together, forms a complete curriculum in modern, humane dog training.

They taught me the “why” behind the science, the “how” of practical application, and the specialized techniques for the toughest challenges.

This is the library that rebuilt my relationship with Max and can do the same for you and your dog.

Understanding Your Garden’s Ecology (The Foundational ‘Why’)

Before you can cultivate a garden, you must understand the science of life itself—the principles of botany, the composition of soil, the way plants interact with their environment.

These foundational books provide that essential, big-picture knowledge.

They don’t just give you instructions; they change the way you see.

Book 1: Don’t Shoot the Dog! by Karen Pryor

• Role: The Universal Botany Textbook
• Analysis: This book is, without exaggeration, the single most important starting point. Karen Pryor, a pioneering biologist and animal trainer, wasn’t just writing about dogs; she was writing about the fundamental laws of learning that govern the behavior of every living creature, from dolphins to dogs to our own children.²⁹ Reading this book was my first true “Aha!” moment. Pryor masterfully demystifies the science of operant conditioning, explaining concepts like reinforcement, shaping, and stimulus control in witty, accessible prose that makes complex psychology feel like common sense.³¹ For me, the most revolutionary part was her chapter on the eight methods for getting rid of unwanted behavior—only one of which is punishment.³⁴ It opened my eyes to a world of creative, non-confrontational solutions.
  Don’t Shoot the Dog! gave me the scientific bedrock for the Gardener’s Mindset. It proved that kindness wasn’t just a nice idea; it was the most effective technology we have for changing behavior.

Book 2: The Culture Clash by Jean Donaldson

• Role: The Field Guide to Your Specific Plant
• Analysis: If Pryor’s book is the general science of botany, Jean Donaldson’s The Culture Clash is the detailed field guide to the specific, and sometimes alien, species growing in your living room. Donaldson, a giant in the field of dog training, presents a revolutionary idea: most of what we call “bad behavior” in dogs—jumping, chewing, barking, pulling—is simply normal dog behavior that happens to clash with our human culture.³⁵ The book forces you to get the dog’s perspective, to see them not as furry little humans or “training lemons,” but as a distinct species with their own innate drives and motivations.³⁵ This book was a crucial step in my journey with Max. It helped me stop anthropomorphizing his behavior—seeing his reactivity as “defiance” or “aggression”—and start understanding it as a manifestation of his canine nature clashing with a stressful environment.³⁹ It taught me to stop blaming my dog and start understanding him, which is the first step any good gardener must take.

Book 3: The Other End of the Leash by Patricia B. McConnell

• Role: The Gardener’s Self-Reflection Manual
• Analysis: This book was perhaps the most humbling and transformative of all. After learning the science of behavior and the dog’s perspective, Dr. Patricia McConnell, a Ph.D. in Zoology and an applied animal behaviorist, turns the lens 180 degrees and points it directly at the human.³² She brilliantly explains how our own primate behaviors—like direct eye contact, hugging, and our tendency to use sharp, loud vocal tones when stressed—can be deeply confusing or even threatening to our canine companions.³¹ I realized with dawning horror how my own tense body language, my tight leash, and my frustrated sighs were pouring gasoline on the fire of Max’s anxiety. I thought I was being a strong leader; from his perspective, I was a tense, unpredictable primate telegraphing danger.
  The Other End of the Leash is essential reading because it teaches the gardener that they are the most significant part of the garden’s ecosystem. To cultivate a calm dog, you must first learn to be a calm primate.

Planting the Seeds (The Practical ‘How-To’)

With a solid understanding of the science and ecology of your garden, it’s time to get your hands dirty.

These books are the practical, step-by-step guides that show you how to plant the seeds of good behavior and build a thriving relationship from the ground up.

Book 4: The Power of Positive Dog Training by Pat Miller

• Role: The Step-by-Step Planting Guide
• Analysis: After the theoretical deep dive of the first three books, Pat Miller’s work was a welcome breath of fresh, practical air. This is the book that takes the Gardener’s philosophy and turns it into a concrete action plan.⁴² Miller, a highly respected trainer who herself transitioned from traditional to positive methods, provides an easy-to-follow, six-week basic training program using a clicker and positive reinforcement.³¹ Her instructions are clear, compassionate, and focused on building a relationship based on friendship and trust, not fear and punishment.⁴⁴ For Max and me, this book was our roadmap back from the brink. It gave us a shared language and a series of small, achievable successes that began to rebuild the trust my old methods had eroded. It’s the perfect first hands-on tool for any new gardener.

Book 5: Puppy Start Right by Kenneth Martin, DVM & Debbie Martin, RVT

• Role: The Seedling and Soil Preparation Manual
• Analysis: For anyone starting with a puppy, this book is non-negotiable. It is the definitive guide to preparing the soil correctly from the very beginning to prevent a lifetime of problems. Co-authored by a board-certified veterinary behaviorist and a certified veterinary technician specialist in behavior, Puppy Start Right is the gold standard for puppy raising, grounded in science and veterinary medicine.³¹ It covers the critical socialization period, problem prevention, house-training, and foundational behaviors in a comprehensive, easy-to-follow format. While I adopted Max as an adult, this is the book I give to every friend who is about to get a puppy. It is the ultimate preventative medicine, teaching you how to cultivate a healthy, well-adjusted garden before the weeds even have a chance to sprout.

Tending to Tough Spots (Advanced & Specialty Guides for Reactivity)

Even the most well-tended garden can have tough spots—invasive weeds, pests, or diseases that require specialized knowledge.

For dog owners, this often means dealing with complex behavioral issues like fear, anxiety, and reactivity.

These books are the advanced tools for those specific challenges.

Book 6: Click to Calm: Healing the Aggressive Dog by Emma Parsons

• Role: The First-Aid Kit for Reactivity
• Analysis: When you’re dealing with the scary and overwhelming problem of reactivity, you need a clear, structured, and safe plan. Click to Calm is that plan. Emma Parsons provides a systematic protocol that uses the precision of a clicker and the power of positive reinforcement to change a dog’s emotional response to their triggers.⁴⁶ This book was my first-aid kit. It gave me a set of foundational exercises, like “Look At That” (LAT), that provided a safe and structured way to begin addressing Max’s fear of other dogs. It’s a lifeline for owners who feel lost and need a concrete starting point to regain control and start the healing process.

Book 7: Behavior Adjustment Training (BAT) 2.0 by Grisha Stewart

• Role: The Advanced Ecological Restoration Guide
• Analysis: If Click to Calm is the first-aid kit, Grisha Stewart’s BAT 2.0 is the advanced manual for ecological restoration. This approach is the epitome of the Gardener’s Mindset. BAT is a nuanced and empowering protocol designed to help dogs with fear, frustration, and aggression by giving them choice and control.⁴¹ Instead of just rewarding a dog for looking at you, BAT uses functional rewards—like the ability to move away, sniff the ground, or gather information from a safe distance—to help the dog learn to navigate the world on its own terms. It requires careful leash handling and an ability to read your dog’s subtle body language, but it is profoundly effective. It teaches the gardener how to arrange the environment so the dog can learn, grow, and build its own confidence.

Book 8: Control Unleashed: Reactive to Relaxed by Leslie McDevitt

• Role: The Trellis and Support System
• Analysis: Some dogs, especially those who are anxious, over-aroused, or easily distracted, need more than just good soil; they need a structure to grow on. Leslie McDevitt’s Control Unleashed program provides that structure. This book is a treasure trove of pattern games and focus exercises that create predictability in what can feel like a chaotic world for a reactive dog.⁴⁶ These games—like the “Look at That” game or “Up/Down” patterns—are not about rigid obedience. They are about creating a shared language of rituals that help a dog feel safe, focus on their handler, and relax even when triggers are present. For Max, these games were like a sturdy trellis, giving him a predictable and rewarding structure to cling to when he felt overwhelmed, allowing him to grow strong and confident instead of collapsing into a reactive heap.

Table 1: The Modern Dog Owner’s Essential Bookshelf
Book Title	Author(s)	Primary Focus	Best For…
Don’t Shoot the Dog!	Karen Pryor	The universal science of learning and behavior.	Every single pet owner. The foundational “why” behind modern training.
The Culture Clash	Jean Donaldson	Understanding the dog’s perspective and innate behaviors.	Owners who want to move beyond anthropomorphism and understand their dog as a dog.
The Other End of the Leash	Patricia B. McConnell	How human primate behavior affects our dogs.	Every owner who wants to improve their communication and relationship with their dog.
The Power of Positive Dog Training	Pat Miller	A practical, step-by-step positive reinforcement training program.	New dog owners or those new to positive training who need a clear “how-to” guide.
Puppy Start Right	Kenneth Martin & Debbie Martin	Comprehensive puppy raising, socialization, and problem prevention.	Anyone getting a new puppy. The essential guide for starting right.
Click to Calm	Emma Parsons	A structured protocol for addressing reactivity and aggression.	Owners of reactive dogs who need a clear, safe, and effective starting point.
Behavior Adjustment Training (BAT) 2.0	Grisha Stewart	An advanced, empowerment-based approach for fear and frustration.	Owners ready to give their dogs more choice and control to build resilience.
Control Unleashed: Reactive to Relaxed	Leslie McDevitt	Pattern games and exercises to build focus and confidence in anxious dogs.	Owners of dogs that are easily over-aroused, distracted, or anxious in new environments.

Conclusion: The Joy of the Harvest

Just last week, Max and I were at an outdoor cafe.

It’s something I wouldn’t have dared to dream of two years ago.

A woman walked by with a small, bouncy terrier.

The old Max would have erupted, sending tables and chairs flying in his panic.

The old me would have tensed, choked up on the leash, and made everything a thousand times worse.

But this time was different.

Max saw the terrier.

I saw his ears prick, his body momentarily stiffen.

But then, instead of exploding, he did something miraculous.

He turned his head and looked at me.

It was a “check-in,” a question.

It was the behavior we had practiced a thousand times, the seed we had planted with the help of Click to Calm and nurtured with the pattern games from Control Unleashed.

I smiled, told him “Good boy,” and gave him a piece of chicken.

He took it gently, and then lay his head down on his paws, letting out a soft sigh as the terrier bounced past.

He had seen the storm cloud, looked to me for the forecast, and realized it was going to be sunny.

That was our harvest.

It wasn’t about obedience; it was a conversation.

My relationship with Max is no longer a battle for control.

It is a partnership built on a foundation of trust, communication, and mutual understanding.

The fear and frustration that once defined our walks have been replaced by a quiet joy and a deep, unshakable bond.

This transformation was not the result of me becoming a tougher “alpha.” It was the result of me humbly admitting I was wrong, throwing away my mechanic’s tools, and learning to become a gardener.

This journey is not always easy.

It requires patience, empathy, and a willingness to look at your own behavior as much as your dog’s.

But it is a journey worth taking.

You have the power to cultivate a better, more beautiful relationship with the dog in your life.

Pick up your first gardening tool—one of these foundational books—and start.

The harvest, I promise you, is more joyful than you can possibly imagine.

Works cited

1. The History of Dog Training, accessed August 13, 2025, https://maggiedogtraining.com/blog/2018/10/9/the-history-of-dog-training
2. Dog Training | EBSCO Research Starters, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/dog-training
3. The Damage of Dog Whispering – Why Animals Do The Thing, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.whyanimalsdothething.com/the-damage-of-dog-whispering
4. Dominance Theory, accessed August 13, 2025, https://iaabc.org/dominance-theory
5. Cesar’s Way: The Natural, Everyday Guide to Understanding & Correcting Common Dog Problems – Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1953153
6. Cesar’s Way: The Natural, Everyday Guide to Understanding & Correcting Common Dog Problems – Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7546.Cesar_s_Way
7. www.goodreads.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34926918-cesar-s-way#:~:text=Cesar%20believes%20that%20in%20order,dog%20them%20in%20that%20order.
8. Dogs are not tiny humans, OK? Now please read ‘Cesar’s Way’ – Essy Knopf, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.essyknopf.com/why-you-should-read-cesars-way/
9. apdt position statement dog training television shows, accessed August 13, 2025, https://apdt.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/APDT-POSITION-STATEMENT-DOG-IMPOSSIBLE-20200406.pdf
10. Why are Cesar Milan’s dog training techniques controversial? : r/DogTrainingTips – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DogTrainingTips/comments/15o79y8/why_are_cesar_milans_dog_training_techniques/
11. The Art of Raising a Puppy by Monks of New Skete | Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32218.The_Art_of_Raising_a_Puppy
12. Review: “The Art of Raising a Puppy” by The Monks of New Skete – words and dirt, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.words-and-dirt.com/words/review-the-art-of-raising-a-puppy-by-the-monks-of-new-skete/
13. Book Review: The Art Of Raising A Puppy by The Monks of New Skete, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.homeskooling4dogs.com/homeskooling-blog/2019/2/24/book-review-the-art-of-raising-a-puppy-by-the-monks-of-new-skete
14. The Art of Raising a Puppy : r/Dogtraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/9a4rmg/the_art_of_raising_a_puppy/
15. Make an Informed Choice: Balanced Dog Training vs. Positive Reinforcement, accessed August 13, 2025, https://lifeunleashed.io/blog/balanced-vs-positive-reinforcement-dog-training/
16. Understanding Balanced Dog Training: Benefits and Techniques, accessed August 13, 2025, https://precisiondogtrainer.com/understanding-balanced-dog-training-benefits-and-techniques/
17. Positive Reinforcement vs. Balanced Training – Good Dog Academy, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.gooddog-academy.com/blog/positive-reinforcement-vs-balanced-training
18. Dog Training Methods and Beliefs- What are the differences? – De Marinis Dog Training & Behavior, accessed August 13, 2025, https://demarinisdogtraining.com/dog-training-methods-and-beliefs-what-are-the-differences/
19. APDT International Standards of Practice, accessed August 13, 2025, https://apdt.com/standards-of-practice/
20. canineacademycolumbus.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://canineacademycolumbus.com/blog/lima-dog-training/#:~:text=LIMA%20dog%20training%20is%20a,of%20punishment%20or%20physical%20force.
21. Understanding LIMA Dog Training: A Humane and Effective Approach, accessed August 13, 2025, https://canineacademycolumbus.com/blog/lima-dog-training/
22. apdt.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://apdt.com/position-statements/#:~:text=The%20APDT%20adheres%20to%20the,tactics%20to%20achieve%20behavior%20change.
23. Regulation in Animal Training and Behavior, accessed August 13, 2025, https://iaabc.org/regulation-in-animal-training-and-behavior
24. LIMA Dog Training Principles: What You Need to Know – Wag!, accessed August 13, 2025, https://wagwalking.com/daily/lima-dog-training-principles-what-you-need-to-know
25. Position statement on LIMA What Do You Want the Animal … – APDT, accessed August 13, 2025, https://apdt.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/position-statement-lima.pdf
26. Positive Dog Training – What Does Science Say?, accessed August 13, 2025, https://happydogtraining.info/general-information/positive-dog-training/
27. Transforming Leash Aggression: A Positive Reinforcement Guide, accessed August 13, 2025, https://dogtrainingmichigan.com/transforming-leash-aggression-a-positive-reinforcement-guide/
28. From Crazy To Calm: A Training Plan For Leash Reactivity – Dr. Jen’s Dog Blog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.drjensdogblog.com/from-crazy-to-calm-a-training-plan-for-leash-reactivity/
29. 52 Self-Help Books in 2019 Project, Week 4: “Don’t Shoot the Dog” by Karen Pryor, accessed August 13, 2025, https://useyourdamnskills.com/2019/01/27/52-self-help-books-in-2019-project-week-4-dont-shoot-the-dog-by-karen-pryor/
30. Don’t Shoot the Dog! (A book review) – Stale Cheerios, accessed August 13, 2025, http://stalecheerios.com/book-and-dvd-reviews/dont-shoot-dog-pryor/
31. The 14 Best Dog Training Books – The Spruce Pets, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.thesprucepets.com/best-dog-training-books-4164678
32. 100 Best Dog Training Books of All Time (Updated for 2025), accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.shortform.com/best-books/genre/best-dog-training-books-of-all-time
33. Book Summary: Don’t Shoot the Dog – Tend the Fire, accessed August 13, 2025, https://fiddlemath.net/2013/08/07/dont-shoot-the-dog/
34. Don’t Shoot the Dog: The Art of Teaching and Training – Dogwise, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.dogwise.com/dont-shoot-the-dog-the-art-of-teaching-and-training/
35. The Culture Clash – A Book by Jean Donaldson – Canine Training Systems, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.caninetrainingsystems.com/product/B-CUL/The-Culture-Clash-A-Book-by-Jean-Donaldson
36. The Culture Clash – Dogwise.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.dogwise.com/the-culture-clash/
37. sobrief.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://sobrief.com/books/culture-clash#:~:text=FAQ-,What’s%20Culture%20Clash%20about%3F,rather%20than%20through%20human%20emotions.
38. Dog’ Education in “The Culture Clash” by Jean Donaldson – 945 Words | Report Example, accessed August 13, 2025, https://ivypanda.com/essays/dog-education-in-the-culture-clash-by-jean-donaldson/
39. ‘The Culture Clash’ by Jean Donaldson | Literary Transgressions – WordPress.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://literarytransgressions.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/the-culture-clash-by-jean-donaldson/
40. Best Dog Psychology and Training Books (90 books) – Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/31720.Best_Dog_Psychology_and_Training_Books
41. My 3 Favorite Books About Training Shy and Fearful Dogs – XO Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://shyandfearfuldogs.com/my-3-favorite-books-about-training-shy-and-fearful-dogs/
42. www.goodreads.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/215767.The_Power_of_Positive_Dog_Training#:~:text=This%20book%20is%20geared%20toward,with%20diary)%20for%20any%20dog.
43. The Power of Positive Dog Training by Pat Miller – Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/215767.The_Power_of_Positive_Dog_Training
44. The Power of Positive Dog Training by Pat Miller, Paperback | Barnes & Noble®, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-power-of-positive-dog-training-pat-miller/1100295797
45. The Power of Positive Dog Training by Pat Miller – Goodreads, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16349579-the-power-of-positive-dog-training
46. Must Read Books for Reactivity? : r/reactivedogs – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/reactivedogs/comments/16kahug/must_read_books_for_reactivity/
47. Reactivity Reading List – Clickstart Dog Training Academy, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.clickstartdogacademy.com/blog/reactivityreadinglist
48. Books – Grisha Stewart Dog Store, accessed August 13, 2025, https://store.grishastewart.com/collections/books