Why I Ditched the Crate and Gave My Dog a Room of Their Own

I’m a veterinary behaviorist.

For over a decade, I’ve dedicated my life to understanding the intricate minds of our canine companions.

I’ve authored papers, guided countless clients through complex behavioral challenges, and, frankly, I thought I had crate training down to a science.

I preached the standard gospel: make it positive, use high-value treats, never use it for punishment.

It was a neat, clean protocol that had always worked.

Then I adopted Max.

Max was a two-year-old rescue, a whirlwind of anxiety wrapped in a scruffy terrier mix coat.

He came with a history I could only guess at, but his fear of confinement was palpable.

I started the process exactly as I would have advised any client.

I bought a standard wire crate, made it comfortable, and began the slow, patient work of positive association.¹

But Max didn’t follow the protocol.

The moment the door was latched, even for a minute, a frantic panic set in.

He would howl, a sound of pure desolation that echoed through the house.

He would spin relentlessly in the small space, rubbing his face raw against the bars in a desperate attempt to escape.³

I tried everything in my professional toolkit: different locations, covering the crate, high-value Kongs frozen with his favorite food, even pheromone diffusers.

Nothing worked.

The crate, which I had always seen as a tool for safety and security, had become a chamber of misery for him.

I was failing my own dog, and it was heartbreaking.

The “safe den” I was trying to create was, in his eyes, nothing more than a cage.

The breakthrough didn’t come from another veterinary conference or a dog training seminar.

It came late one night, deep in a research rabbit hole on a seemingly unrelated topic: child psychology.

I was reading about the principles of creating safe, personal spaces for children—how a child’s own room, when treated with respect, becomes a sanctuary for emotional regulation and building a sense of self.⁴

It was about trust, autonomy, and psychological safety, not just four walls and a door.

Suddenly, everything clicked into place.

The goal was never to “crate” a dog.

It was to provide them with their own bedroom.

This single shift in perspective changed everything.

It wasn’t about finding a better technique; it was about adopting a completely new paradigm.

I wasn’t just confining an animal; I was designing a personal space for a member of my family.

The Personal Room Paradigm: A New Foundation for a Happy Dog

The moment you stop thinking “crate” and start thinking “bedroom,” every decision that follows becomes clearer and more humane.

The question is no longer, “How do I get my dog to tolerate this box?” It becomes, “How do I design a personal space that my dog will love and feel secure in?” This reframes the entire process from an exercise in control to an act of profound care.

Deconstructing the Den Animal Myth

One of the most persistent ideas in dog training is that crates work because they tap into a dog’s “natural denning instinct”.⁷

The image of a wolf curling up in a cozy, dark cave is a powerful and comforting one for owners.

It makes us feel that by crating our dogs, we are fulfilling a deep, primal need.

This idea is promoted by manufacturers and trainers alike because it’s a simple, appealing narrative.¹⁰

The scientific reality, however, is more nuanced.

While wild canids do use dens, they are typically temporary structures used by females for birthing and rearing young pups for a few weeks.⁷

Adult, non-breeding dogs do not live in dens year-round.

In fact, studies of free-ranging domestic dogs show they often choose resting spots with high visibility and easy access to resources, which directly contradicts the idea that they are hard-wired to seek out small, enclosed, hidden spaces.¹³

The “den instinct” is a convenient metaphor, but it’s not the full story.

Many dog owners and even some trainers have astutely pointed out that a crate only functions like a “den” when the door is left open and the dog chooses to enter it freely.¹⁴

The moment the door is latched against their will, it ceases to be a den and becomes a cage.

The real psychological driver behind a crate’s success is not a mystical denning instinct, but a universal need for a predictable, secure, and respected personal territory.

This is where the lessons from child psychology become so powerful.

The success of a crate has less to do with a dog’s distant wolf ancestry and more to do with fulfilling the deep psychological need for a sanctuary—a place of one’s own.

This explains why a crate can fail so spectacularly when it’s just a box, but succeed when it’s treated as a respected personal room.

Lessons from Child Psychology: Building a Foundation of Trust

When we create a bedroom for a child, we understand it’s more than just a place to sleep.

It’s a space that fosters a sense of self, security, and emotional regulation.⁵

The same principles apply to our dogs.

• Trust and Autonomy: A child’s room becomes a sanctuary when their privacy and boundaries are respected. They need to feel a sense of control over their space.⁴ Similarly, a dog must feel that they can enter and exit their “room” freely during the initial training phases. Forcing them in or locking the door before trust is established is like a parent angrily sending a child to their room for punishment; it poisons the space and turns a potential sanctuary into a place of anxiety and resentment.¹⁵
• A Safe Physical Environment: A child’s safe space is calm, quiet, and free from intimidation or overstimulation.⁶ A dog’s crate should be placed in a low-traffic area of the home, away from the chaos of front doors, loud appliances, or other environmental factors that can cause stress.¹⁶ The space itself should be a source of calm, not stimulation.
• Non-Judgmental Support: The foundation of a safe space is trust and rapport.⁶ The space should be associated with positive, calming experiences. It should never be used as a tool for punishment, which creates a negative association that can be incredibly difficult to undo.¹⁷

By applying these principles, we move away from the simplistic idea of a “den” and toward the much more powerful concept of a personal sanctuary built on a foundation of psychological safety.

Designing the Room: How to Choose the Perfect Crate

Once you’ve embraced the “personal room” paradigm, choosing a crate becomes an act of thoughtful design.

You are now an architect, and your client is your dog.

The blueprint must match the crate’s purpose and its resident’s unique personality.

Is this a primary residence for a puppy? A secure mobile home for a frequent traveler? A fortified safe room for an anxious dog?

Materials and Construction: Choosing an Architectural Style

Each type of crate can be thought of as a different architectural style, with distinct advantages and disadvantages.

• The Open-Plan Loft (Wire Crates): These are perhaps the most common choice. Their open design provides excellent ventilation and visibility, making them ideal for confident, easy-going dogs who enjoy being able to see their surroundings.²¹ They are often collapsible for easy storage and are generally the most budget-friendly option.²³
• Crucial Caveat: This style is not suitable for dogs with anxiety or a history of escape attempts, as they can bend the wires or injure themselves trying to get out.²¹ Most critically, standard wire crates are
  extremely dangerous for car travel. In an accident, the wires can break and create sharp, deadly hazards.²¹
• The Cozy Studio (Plastic Crates): These offer a more enclosed, den-like feel that can be very calming for some dogs.²¹ They provide more privacy and block out more visual stimuli. Plastic crates are a step up from wire crates for car safety and are the required standard for most airline travel.²¹
• Crucial Caveat: Cheaper plastic models can be brittle and may crack under stress, creating sharp edges that pose a serious injury risk.²⁶ They also offer less air circulation than wire crates, which can be a concern for brachycephalic (flat-faced) breeds or in warmer climates.²³

• The Fortress of Solitude (Heavy-Duty and Crash-Tested Crates): This is the architectural equivalent of a custom-built, reinforced structure. Made from high-strength materials like heavy-gauge aluminum or single-piece rotomolded plastic, these crates are the gold standard for safety and security.²¹ They are essential for two specific cases: dogs with high anxiety or destructive escape behaviors (like those from Impact Crates) and, most importantly, for safe car travel (like those from Gunner or Ruff Land).²¹
• The Pop-Up Tent (Soft-Sided Crates): These fabric crates are exceptionally lightweight and portable, making them a fantastic choice for well-behaved dogs at events like dog sports, camping trips, or visits to friends’ homes.²¹
• Crucial Caveat: This option is strictly for dogs that are already fully crate-trained and have no tendency to chew or claw. A determined dog can destroy a fabric crate in minutes.²¹ They offer no meaningful protection in a vehicle.²⁸
• The Integrated Suite (Furniture-Style Crates): These crates are designed to blend seamlessly into your home decor, often doubling as end tables or credenzas.²²
• Crucial Caveat: They prioritize form over function. Often constructed from wood or composite materials, they are vulnerable to damage from chewing and can be difficult to clean thoroughly.²⁴ They are a poor choice for puppies in the midst of house-training or for any dog with anxiety or destructive tendencies.

Building Codes: Non-Negotiable Safety Features

Just as a house must meet building codes to be safe for its inhabitants, a dog’s “room” must meet certain non-negotiable safety standards.

This is where a higher price point often reflects superior engineering and materials that are critical for your dog’s well-being.

• Secure Latches: As certified professional dog trainer Nicole Ellis emphasizes, secure latches are paramount, especially for dogs prone to escaping. A good latch system, like the slide-bolt latches on many MidWest crates, is difficult for a dog to manipulate but simple for a human to open quickly in an emergency.²⁶
• No Sharp Edges or Pinch Points: This is a critical safety check highlighted by Lindsey Wolko, founder of the Center for Pet Safety (CPS). Carefully inspect any crate for sturdy joints, smoothly rounded edges, and secure connections. There should be no gaps where a paw, nose, or jaw could get caught and injured.²⁶ This is a common failure point in cheaply manufactured wire crates. The Diggs Revol crate, with its diamond-shaped mesh and rounded frame, is a prime example of a design that prioritizes this aspect of safety.²⁶
• Structural Integrity and Materials: Wolko specifically warns against inexpensive plastic crates that are prone to fracturing, creating dangerous sharp shards.²⁶ The superior structural integrity of a heavy-duty crate is evident in designs like the double-walled rotomolded plastic of a Gunner kennel, which provides significant impact protection.²⁶
• Adequate Ventilation: Proper airflow is essential to prevent overheating and ensure your dog’s comfort. All crates, including heavy-duty models, must have well-designed ventilation holes or mesh panels.²²
• Crash-Test Certification: This is the ultimate building code for any crate used in a vehicle. A crate is not “safe for the car” just because it fits inside. To offer real protection in an accident, it must be specifically designed and tested for crash safety. The Center for Pet Safety (CPS) provides independent certification, with the Gunner G1 kennel being a notable 5-star rated example.²⁶ Furthermore, the crate must be properly secured in the vehicle with strength-rated anchor straps—never with bungee cords.²⁶

Sizing the Space: The Just Right Principle

The size of the room is critical for both comfort and function.

The universal rule, agreed upon by veterinarians and trainers, is that the crate must be large enough for your dog to comfortably stand up without ducking, turn around easily, and lie down fully stretched O.T.²⁰

A good guideline is to measure your dog’s height (head to floor) and length (nose to base of tail) and add 2 to 4 inches to each dimension to find the minimum required crate size.²⁵

However, there’s a common pitfall with puppies.

If the crate is too large, a puppy may designate one end as a sleeping area and the other as a bathroom, which completely undermines the house-training process.²²

The solution is elegant and economical: purchase a crate that will fit your dog’s expected adult size but ensure it comes with an adjustable divider panel.²¹

This allows you to create a smaller, appropriately-sized space for your puppy and then gradually move the divider back as they grow.

This single feature saves you from buying multiple crates and is one of the most important aspects to look for when choosing a “starter home” for a puppy.²⁹

The Housewarming: A Step-by-Step Guide to Positive Association

With the room designed and built, it’s time for the housewarming.

This is the most critical phase, where you transform the physical structure into a beloved sanctuary.

This process must be slow, patient, and rooted in positive reinforcement, as championed by experts like the Karen Pryor Academy.²

The goal is not to teach tolerance of confinement, but to cultivate a genuine love for the space.

Step 1: The Welcome Mat (Pressure-Free Introduction)

First impressions matter.

Place the new crate in a common area of the house where your family spends time, like the living room or kitchen.¹

Securely tie the door open so it cannot swing shut and startle your dog.

Then, do nothing.

Let your dog investigate it on their own terms.

To encourage exploration, casually toss high-value treats near the crate, then just inside the entrance, and finally all the way to the back.¹

Never force, push, or lure your dog inside.

The choice to enter must be theirs.

This initial phase is all about building curiosity and a positive first association.

Step 2: Interior Decorating (Making it Comfortable)

Make the room a five-star suite.

Line it with a comfortable, non-slip bed or soft blankets.³¹

Add an old t-shirt or blanket that smells like you to provide comfort.¹¹

Most importantly, introduce special toys or food puzzles that are

exclusively available in the crate.¹¹

This makes the space uniquely high-value.

For some dogs, draping a blanket over the top and sides of the crate can enhance the cozy, secure feeling, but others may prefer the visibility of an uncovered crate; observe your dog’s preference.²⁰

Step 3: Handing Over the Keys (Building Voluntary Entry)

This step forges the connection between the room and wonderful things.

• Mealtime Magic: Begin feeding all of your dog’s meals inside the crate. At first, leave the door wide open. As they become comfortable, you can start to briefly close the door while they are eating, opening it again before they finish.¹
• Cue and Reward: Choose a verbal cue, like “Crate,” “Kennel,” or “Room,” and say it in a happy, upbeat tone every time you toss a treat inside.³¹ Soon, your dog will begin to enter eagerly on cue.
• Make it a Game: Turn crate time into the best part of the day. Hide treats under a blanket inside for them to find. Use a long-lasting food puzzle, like a KONG toy stuffed with peanut butter or wet food and then frozen, to create a prolonged, positive experience.² The goal is for your dog to rush into their room with joyful anticipation.

Step 4: Establishing House Rules (Duration and Boundaries)

Once your dog loves entering their room, you can begin to work on duration.

Start by closing the door for just a few seconds while you are still sitting right there, then open it.

Gradually increase the time in tiny increments.¹

During this process, two rules are absolute:

1. The Golden Rule: Never Use the Crate for Punishment. This is the fastest and most effective way to destroy all the trust you have built. The room must remain a sanctuary, never a jail cell. If your dog has an accident or chews something they shouldn’t, putting them in the crate while you clean up is fine, but it should never be done with anger or as a punitive act.¹⁵
2. The Whining Rule: Never Open the Door on Demand. If your dog starts whining, crying, or barking to be let out, you must wait. It is imperative that you do not open the door until there is a brief moment of quiet. If you let them out while they are vocalizing, you are teaching them that making noise is the key that opens the door.¹ This can be difficult, but patience is crucial. If the whining is persistent, you have likely increased the duration too quickly. Make the next session shorter and more successful.

The ultimate goal of this process is not simply to teach a dog to stay in a box.

It is to teach a dog the invaluable life skill of how to settle, self-soothe, and be calm and relaxed in their own personal space.

This is a shift from a physical goal (containment) to a psychological one (emotional regulation).

A dog that has learned to be content in their “bedroom” is a dog that has learned how to be comfortably independent, a skill that will serve them for their entire life.

When They Hate Their Room: Troubleshooting Crate Aversion and Anxiety

Sometimes, despite our best efforts, a dog develops a strong aversion to the crate.

For my dog Max, the crate was a source of terror.

This is where a diagnostic, compassionate approach is essential.

Step 1: The Diagnostic – Is It the Room or Is It Loneliness?

Before you can solve the problem, you must correctly identify it.

It is critical to differentiate between two distinct conditions:

• Confinement Anxiety: This is a fear of the enclosed space itself. A dog with confinement anxiety will show signs of panic—panting, drooling, trying to escape—even when you are in the same room.¹⁶
• Separation Anxiety: This is a panic disorder related to being left alone. A dog with separation anxiety might be perfectly calm in the crate as long as you are present, but will begin to panic the moment you prepare to leave or shortly after you are gone.³

This distinction is not academic; it is a matter of safety.

Crating a dog with true separation anxiety is not a solution; it is often dangerous and can make the problem worse. The dog’s panic is not about the box; it’s about the terror of being abandoned.

Confining them during this panic can lead to intense escape attempts, resulting in broken teeth, torn nails, and other serious injuries.¹⁵

If you suspect your dog has separation anxiety, the solution is not a stronger crate.

The solution is to consult a veterinary behaviorist or a certified professional to address the underlying emotional disorder.³⁷

Step 2: The Renovation Plan – Changing a Negative Association

If the issue is confinement anxiety or a learned hatred of the crate, you need a renovation plan.

• Identify and Remove the Aversive: First, play detective. Why does your dog hate the room? Were they left in it for too long and forced to soil it? Is it in a loud, drafty, or high-traffic location? Was a scary event associated with it? Was it ever used for punishment? You must identify and eliminate the source of the negative association.¹⁶
• Start from Scratch with a New Model: Often, the most effective strategy is to get a completely new and different type of crate.³² The old crate is “haunted” by bad memories. If they hated a noisy wire crate, the quiet, enclosed nature of a plastic crate might feel safer. This change in architecture helps to break the old association and gives you a clean slate.
• Go Back to the Beginning: With the new crate, you must go all the way back to the beginning of “The Housewarming” process. This is a slow, patient journey of counter-conditioning and desensitization, rebuilding trust from the ground up.¹⁶

Step 3: The Relocation Plan – When the Room Isn’t Working

For some dogs, particularly those with a history of trauma or severe anxiety, a traditional crate may never be the right answer.

That is okay.

The goal is safe, comfortable management, and there are other options.

• The Gated Community (Exercise Pens): An exercise pen, or “x-pen,” offers more space than a crate and can feel significantly less confining for many dogs, while still keeping them safely contained.¹⁵ You can even place their open-door crate inside the pen to give them a cozy sleeping option.
• The Private Suite (Dog-Proofed Room): Another excellent alternative is to use baby gates to secure your dog in a single, dog-proofed room, such as a laundry room, bathroom, or kitchen.¹⁵ This provides the safety of confinement without the intensity of a small, enclosed box. For some dogs, having more space actually reduces their anxiety.³⁶

The Expert’s Showroom: Top Crate Recommendations for Every Need

Choosing a crate is a significant investment in your dog’s safety and well-being.

This isn’t just a list of products; it’s a curated showroom of “model homes,” each designed and architected for a specific need and lifestyle.

Use this table to diagnose your situation and find the perfect fit.

Crate Model & Brand	Architectural Style	Best For (Primary Use Case)	Material & Construction	Key Safety Feature	Price Point
MidWest Homes for Pets iCrate 27	The Open-Plan Starter Home	Basic home use for a confident puppy; budget-conscious choice.	Coated Steel Wire, Plastic Pan	Secure slide-bolt latches; includes essential puppy divider.	$
Diggs Revol Dog Crate 24	The Upgraded Studio Apartment	Aesthetics and enhanced safety for home use; ideal for puppies.	Steel Mesh, Reinforced Plastic, Aluminum	Diamond-shaped mesh and rounded frame prevent injury; ceiling hatch.	$$$
Ruff Land Kennel 21	The All-Terrain Bunk	Versatile car and home use; excellent balance of safety and value for travel.	Single-Piece Rotomolded Plastic	One-piece construction absorbs impact; superior to wire/basic plastic in a crash.	$$$
Gunner G1 Kennel 21	The Armored SUV	Ultimate, verified car crash safety; for owners who prioritize travel security above all.	Double-Wall Rotomolded Plastic	5-Star CPS Crash-Test Certified; double-walled for maximum impact protection.	$$$$
Impact High Anxiety Crate 21	The Fortress of Solitude	Confirmed escape artists and dogs with severe confinement anxiety.	Heavy-Gauge Welded Aluminum	Escape-proof guarantee; designed to prevent self-injury during escape attempts.	$$$$$

Detailed Reviews

• MidWest Homes for Pets iCrate: This is the quintessential “starter home” for a reason. It’s affordable, widely available, and crucially, it comes with the divider panel needed for a growing puppy.²⁷ Its two-door design offers placement flexibility, and the removable pan makes cleanup simple. However, its wire construction makes it a poor choice for anxious dogs or for use in a vehicle.²¹
• Diggs Revol Dog Crate: This is the “designer apartment” for the safety-conscious owner. While expensive, the Revol is praised by trainers for its thoughtful, safety-first design.²⁷ The diamond-shaped steel mesh prevents paws and jaws from getting caught, the frame is rounded to avoid injury, and the unique ceiling hatch allows you to comfort your dog or deliver a treat without opening the main door. Its collapsible design with wheels also makes it surprisingly mobile for such a sturdy home unit.²⁴
• Ruff Land Kennel: This is the rugged, “all-terrain vehicle” of dog crates. Its single-piece rotomolded plastic construction makes it vastly safer for car travel than any wire or standard plastic crate, as it’s designed to absorb impact rather than shatter or break into sharp pieces.²¹ While not independently crash-tested to the same level as a Gunner, it has a strong reputation among canine professionals for protecting dogs in real-world accidents and offers a fantastic balance of high-level safety and value.²¹
• Gunner G1 Kennel: This is the “armored transport” and the undisputed champion of vehicle safety. It is one of the few crates to earn a 5-star crash-test rating from the Center for Pet Safety.²⁶ Its double-walled rotomolded plastic construction provides unparalleled impact protection. If you frequently travel with your dog in the car and their safety is your absolute top priority, the Gunner is the investment that provides true peace of mind. It is the ultimate expression of treating a dog’s safety with the same seriousness as a human family member’s.
• Impact High Anxiety Crate: This is the “maximum-security safe room” for the dog who can escape or destroy anything else. Constructed from heavy-gauge, welded aluminum, it is guaranteed escape-proof and comes with a lifetime warranty against dog-caused damage.²⁶ The ventilation holes are small and strategically placed to prevent a dog from getting its teeth or claws caught. For a dog suffering from severe confinement anxiety and destructive behavior, this crate can be a literal lifesaver, preventing self-injury and providing secure containment when all other options have failed.²¹

Conclusion: A Shift in Mindset, A Lifetime of Trust

My journey with Max, from the frustration of a “failed” crate training protocol to the success of providing him with his own “room,” was not about finding a magic crate or a secret technique.

It was about a fundamental shift in perspective.

It was about realizing that the tools and methods of my profession needed to be guided by a deeper empathy—an understanding that came not from a textbook, but from the world of human psychology.

The most effective, humane, and loving way to approach this process is to see it not as an act of confinement, but as an act of providing a safe, respected, personal space for a cherished member of your family.

A crate is not a place you put a dog; it is a room you give a dog.

By understanding the psychology of safety, prioritizing robust design and engineering, and building a foundation of trust through patient, positive association, you can move beyond the box.

You can give your dog a true sanctuary—a room of their own that will not only keep them safe and comfortable but will also deepen and strengthen the incredible bond you share for a lifetime.

Works cited

1. How To Crate Train Your Dog – PAWS, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.paws.org/resources/how-to-crate-train-your-dog/
2. Karen Pryor Academy’s – Positive Crate Training Guide, accessed August 13, 2025, https://karenpryoracademy.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Karen_Pryor_Academy_Crate_Training_Guide-PDF.pdf
3. Crate Issues : r/dogs – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/dogs/comments/1ehm7gi/crate_issues/
4. Personal space: A social skill children need and adults can teach …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/personal_space_a_social_skill_children_need_and_adults_can_teach
5. The Importance of Personal Space in Child Development – Psychology Town, accessed August 13, 2025, https://psychology.town/environmental/importance-personal-space-child-development/
6. Creating Safe Spaces for Children to Disclose Abuse: A Critical Approach – NCACIA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ncacia.org/post/creating-safe-spaces-for-children-to-disclose-abuse-a-critical-approach
7. Why Every Dog Needs a Den | ZenCrate, accessed August 13, 2025, https://zendogcrate.com/blogs/news/why-every-dog-needs-a-den
8. Crate Training Your Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.brown.edu/Research/Colwill_Lab/CBP/Crate.htm
9. Crate Training: How To Make Your Dog Love Their Crate, accessed August 13, 2025, https://offleashk9nova.com/crate-training-for-dogs/
10. DOGS AND PUPPIES: Crate Training, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.hsppr.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Crate-Training.pdf
11. The Importance of Crate Training Dogs, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.nomnomnow.com/learn/article/the-importance-of-crate-training
12. Crate Training: One Approach to House-‐training and the Prevention of Destructive Behaviors, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.hssv.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Crate-Training.pdf
13. Dogs and Dens: do crates actually satisfy a dog’s natural denning instincts?, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.confidentmutts.com/mutt-talk/are-dogs-den-animals
14. [Link] Is a dog crate really a den? How this very American practice took off – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/dogs/comments/dfymz3/link_is_a_dog_crate_really_a_den_how_this_very/
15. Confusion about crates – is it dog abuse? : r/Dogtraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/2wevdv/confusion_about_crates_is_it_dog_abuse/
16. Dog Crate Anxiety – Whole Dog Journal, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/training/crates/what-to-do-when-your-dog-hates-his-crate/
17. Common Misconceptions About Dog Crate Training – Direct Animal, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.directanimal.com/dog-kennel-tips/common-misconceptions-about-dog-crate-training/
18. The First Five Years: Creating a Safe Space for Early Childhood Learning, accessed August 13, 2025, https://westonschool.com/first-five-years-creating-safe-space-early-childhood-learning/
19. Providing a Safe Space Through Counseling for Children | Advanced Therapy Clinic, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.advancedtherapyclinic.com/blog/providing-a-safe-space-through-counseling-for-children
20. Playpen and crate training a puppy – RSPCA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.rspca.org.uk/adviceandwelfare/pets/dogs/environment/crates
21. What is the best type of crate for my dog? – Cosmic Canine, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.cosmiccanine.com/what-is-the-best-crate-for-my-dog/
22. Crates for Dogs: How to Choose the Best Dog Crate, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/lifestyle/choose-best-crate-dog/
23. How to Choose a Dog Crate – WebMD, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.webmd.com/pets/dogs/how-to-choose-a-dog-crate
24. The Best Dog Crates of 2025 | GearJunkie Tested, accessed August 13, 2025, https://gearjunkie.com/dogs/the-best-dog-crates
25. Tips for Choosing a Dog Crate – Zoetis Petcare, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.zoetispetcare.com/blog/article/choosing-dog-crate
26. Best Dog Crates 2025 – Forbes Vetted, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbes-personal-shopper/article/best-dog-crate/
27. The 4 Best Dog Crates for Puppies of 2025, Tested And Reviewed – The Spruce Pets, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.thesprucepets.com/best-dog-crates-for-puppies-8549433
28. Question about crates for events/trials! : r/k9sports – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/k9sports/comments/t0cjls/question_about_crates_for_eventstrials/
29. How To Choose the Right Crate Size for Your Dog or Puppy – PetMD, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.petmd.com/dog/general-health/crate-sizing-for-dogs
30. www.vet.cornell.edu, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.vet.cornell.edu/departments-centers-and-institutes/riney-canine-health-center/canine-health-information/dog-crates-when-use-them-and-how-pick-one#:~:text=If%20you%20are%20acquiring%20a,around%20and%20lay%20down%20comfortably.
31. Make Crate Training Your Dog A Positive Experience! – Pawsitive K9 Solutions, accessed August 13, 2025, https://pawsitivek9solution.com/2022/06/08/make-crate-training-your-dog-a-positive-experience/
32. Teach Your Anxious Dog to Be Calm in a Dog Crate | Chewy, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.chewy.com/education/dog/training-and-behavior/how-to-teach-your-dog-to-be-calm-in-a-dog-crate
33. www.humaneworld.org, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.humaneworld.org/en/resources/crate-training-101#:~:text=Give%20them%20a%20voice%20cue,room%20for%20a%20few%20minutes.
34. PSA on crate training : r/Dogtraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/1j3e9g/psa_on_crate_training/
35. The Crate Controversy | – Pawsitively Genius Dog Training and Behaviour, accessed August 13, 2025, http://pawsitivelygenius.com/the-crate-controversy/
36. Separation Anxiety and Your Dog – MSPCA-Angell, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.mspca.org/pet_resources/separation-anxiety-and-your-dog/
37. Crate Training Your Puppy – UC Davis Veterinary Medicine, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.vetmed.ucdavis.edu/sites/g/files/dgvnsk491/files/inline-files/Crate_Training_Your_Puppy.pdf
38. Crate Training Done Right – Pet Behavior Change, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.petbehaviorchange.com/blog/2017/9/8/crate-training-done-right
39. Dog Crate Anxiety: 8 Ways To Reduce Anxiety – Diggs – Diggs Pet, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.diggs.pet/blog/crate-training/dog-crate-anxiety/
40. 10 Best Dog Crates 2025: According to Reviews – Chewy, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.chewy.com/best/dog-crates_s136364