How My Dog Turned Heeling into a Heartfelt Connection

My shoulder ached.

The nylon leash was a taut, vibrating line of failure connecting my tense fist to my dog, Leo, who was currently impersonating a furry tractor.

This was our “walk of shame,” a daily ritual where my 60-pound bundle of joy pulled me down the block, his nose vacuuming the pavement while my heart sank with every lurch.

I saw the looks from neighbors—a mix of pity and judgment.

I felt the hot flush of embarrassment.

I’d read the books, I’d watched the videos, but every walk felt like a public declaration of my incompetence.

Leo wasn’t a “bad dog”; he was a great dog.

But our connection frayed and snapped the moment I clipped on his leash.

The advice I got felt like trying to fix a complex engine with either a hammer or a candy bar.

“Be the alpha,” one camp said.

“Just use more treats,” said the other.

Both left me feeling more lost.

I was failing the dog I loved, and I was desperate for an answer.

What I didn’t know then was that the solution wasn’t a better tool or a tastier treat.

It was a complete shift in perspective, a new way of thinking about the walk itself, that would transform our struggle into something beautiful.

Chapter 1: The War of Wills – Why the Two Dominant Philosophies Failed Me

My journey into the world of teaching a “heel” began like many others: with a pocketful of hope and a deep dive into the two prevailing training philosophies.

Each promised a path to success, but for Leo and me, they both led to a dead end, leaving us more disconnected than when we started.

The Positive Reinforcement Trap: A Pocketful of Bribes

Initially, I embraced purely positive reinforcement with the zeal of a new convert.

Armed with a clicker and a pouch full of freeze-dried liver, I was ready.¹

In the quiet of our living room, it was magic.

Leo, a smart and food-motivated dog, quickly learned that walking nicely by my leg for a few steps earned him a click and a treat.

He was a heeling champion—between the couch and the coffee table.

The moment we stepped outside, however, that magic vanished.

The high-value treat that was king indoors became utterly worthless in the face of a squirrel, a rustling leaf, or the scent of another dog.³

This is a common frustration; the principles of operant conditioning, specifically positive reinforcement (

+R, adding something good to increase a behavior) and negative punishment (−P, removing something good to decrease a behavior), are scientifically sound.¹

The problem lay in my application.

By constantly luring Leo with food, I hadn’t taught him the value of being by my side; I had taught him the value of following my hand.⁶

This created a frustrating “yo-yo” effect many owners will recognize: Leo would surge ahead, I’d stop, call him back, he’d return for the treat, and then immediately lunge forward again to the end of the leash.⁸

Our walk wasn’t a walk; it was a series of frantic, two-step negotiations.

The core issue was that our relationship on the walk had become transactional.

I was “paying” for the heel with treats.

The moment the environment offered a higher payout—the thrill of a chase, a fascinating smell—I was outbid.

My training had inadvertently framed our connection as a simple cost-benefit analysis for Leo, and the outside world was always offering a better deal.

The focus was on the reward, not on the shared state of walking together.

The Balanced Training Dilemma: A Question of Trust

Frustrated and desperate for control, I cautiously explored the world of balanced training.

This approach utilizes all four quadrants of operant conditioning, incorporating not just rewards but also “corrections” to communicate “no” to the dog.⁹

I read the arguments distinguishing “correction” from “punishment,” with proponents explaining that a quick leash “pop” from a prong collar wasn’t meant to inflict pain but to provide clear information and break the dog’s focus.¹⁰

And to be fair, it offered a semblance of control.

The pulling decreased.

But a new, unwelcome tension crept into our walks.

I was constantly on edge, anticipating the next “mistake” that would require a correction.

Leo, in turn, seemed to be walking not with joy, but with a kind of cautious compliance, learning to avoid pressure rather than choosing to be with me.

While the method can produce results, I felt our trust eroding.³

Was this the relationship I wanted? One based on my ability to physically correct him into position?

This journey revealed a hidden flaw in the popular debate.

The “Positive vs. Balanced” argument presents a false dichotomy, forcing owners into the role of either a “treat dispenser” or a “disciplinarian.” When applied to heeling, both philosophies often share a common focus: controlling the dog’s body.

The positive lure aims to guide the body into position; the balanced correction aims to pressure the body back into position.

Neither inherently addresses the dog’s mind or its internal desire to be in a focused partnership.

They were two different tactics aimed at the same superficial goal, and for us, the deeper problem—our lack of a shared mental state—remained completely unsolved.

Chapter 2: The Epiphany – Heeling Isn’t a Command, It’s a Dance

My breakthrough came not from a training seminar or a dog-eared book, but from a late-night trip down a YouTube rabbit hole.

I stumbled upon a video of a “Heelwork to Music” (HTM) competition, also known as Canine Freestyle.¹³

I watched, mesmerized, as a woman and her Border Collie moved across a floor in what could only be described as a dance.

The dog was in a perfect heel position, but it wasn’t the rigid, militaristic heel I had envisioned.

It was fluid, joyful, and breathtakingly connected.

The dog’s eyes were on its handler, its body moving in perfect synchrony with hers—spinning, weaving, and trotting backwards, all with a loose leash and a wagging tail.¹⁶

There was no constant luring with treats, no tense leash corrections.

There was just a palpable, electric connection.

That was my “Aha!” moment.

The lightning bolt of insight that changed everything.

Heeling is not a static position to be enforced; it is a dynamic, rhythmic, moving partnership—a dance.

This analogy became my new paradigm, reframing the entire goal from “obedience” to “harmony” and “teamwork”.¹⁷

A good dance partner doesn’t drag you across the floor; they guide you.

A good dance requires both partners to be exquisitely aware of each other’s position, rhythm, and intention.

You learn the basic steps in a quiet studio before you try a complex routine in a crowded ballroom.

And the point of it all isn’t just to hit your marks; it’s to create a shared, joyful experience.

This shift was profound.

It made me realize that the ultimate goal of teaching a “heel” should not be to get the dog’s shoulder perfectly aligned with my pant seam.

That is merely a byproduct.

The true goal is to create a state of shared focus and connection in motion.

By reframing the goal from a physical position to a mental state of partnership, all the common problems took on a new meaning.

A dog forging ahead was no longer “disobeying the heel command”; they were “rushing the tempo of the dance.” A dog lagging behind was “falling out of rhythm.” A dog sniffing the ground was “distracted from their dance partner.” This simple change forced me to stop asking, “Why is my dog being disobedient?” and start asking, “Why is my partner disconnected?” That question leads to infinitely more productive and relationship-building solutions.

Chapter 3: Learning the Steps – Foundational “Dance” Skills

A dance isn’t a single move; it’s a sequence of skills built upon a solid foundation.

Before Leo and I could attempt our “dance” on the sidewalk, we had to go back to the studio—our living room—and learn the component parts.

This meant breaking the heel down and teaching the individual skills before ever asking for them to be put together in motion.

Engaging Your Partner: “Will You Dance With Me?”

Before you can dance, your partner has to want to be on the dance floor with you.

The first step was to make being near me the most wonderful thing in the world.

This is a core principle of relationship-based training: building a deep well of positive association, or a “reinforcement bank account,” that you can draw from later.¹⁹

Instead of demanding a heel, I started rewarding Leo for simply choosing to be near me.

We played games where I would reward him for voluntary eye contact or for just orienting his body toward me.

There were no commands.

If he was lying across the room and got up to come check in with me, he’d get quiet praise and a treat.

The goal was to build a powerful magnetic pull, teaching him that my personal space was a source of great things.²¹

This wasn’t about luring; it was about reinforcing his own good choices, which is the bedrock of true teamwork.

Body Awareness & The Dance Floor: Defining the Space

A dancer needs to know where their body is in space.

One of the biggest mistakes I had made was trying to teach Leo the heel position and forward motion at the same time.

This insight, borrowed from gundog training, is revolutionary: teach the position as a stationary concept first.²³

By isolating the variable of

position from the variable of motion, you dramatically reduce the dog’s confusion.

We used two key tools to build this body awareness:

• Pivot Platforms: Using a low, stable platform (like a heavy-duty feed pan or a purpose-made pivot dish), I taught Leo to place his front paws on the platform while keeping his back paws on the floor. From there, I could lure him in a circle, teaching him to move his rear end independently of his front. This is a cornerstone of competitive obedience and freestyle training, and it’s invaluable for teaching a dog the “swing finish” into a perfect heel position and preventing them from swinging their butt out wide (“crabbing”) on turns.¹⁹
• Walls and Barriers: We practiced in a narrow hallway. By using the wall as a physical guide, Leo learned to keep his body straight without me needing to constantly correct him. The wall did the work, providing gentle, consistent feedback that helped him understand the feeling of a straight alignment.²⁵

By teaching the heel position as a “place”—just like “sit” or “down”—I was using a concept Leo already understood and applying it to a new physical shape.

We were defining our dance space before we ever took a step.

Chapter 4: The Choreography – A Step-by-Step Guide to the Moving Heel

With the foundational skills in place, it was time to add movement.

This is the choreography phase, where we string the steps together.

But keeping with our new paradigm, every action was framed not as a command to be obeyed, but as a cue in our ongoing dance.

Leading the Dance: The Lure as a Guiding Hand

The food lure, which had previously been my crutch and my bribe, was now repurposed.

It became a temporary tool, like a dance instructor’s hand on my back, gently guiding me through the steps until I learned the feel of the movement myself.

The technique is crucial.

The treat-holding hand must be held stationary at the seam of your pants, on the side you want your dog to heel.²⁶

If the hand moves forward, it will encourage the dog to forge ahead.

For smaller dogs, smearing peanut butter or cream cheese on the end of a long wooden spoon is a back-saving trick that keeps the lure at the correct height.²⁹

We would take one step, and as Leo moved with me, I’d reward him.

Then two steps, then three.

The most critical part, and where many owners fail, is fading the lure.

Once Leo understood the movement, my hand would remain in the same position, but empty.

The reward would come from my other hand or a treat pouch after he successfully completed a few steps.⁷

This breaks the dependency on the lure and teaches the dog to stay in position because of the position itself, not because there’s a constant snack at their nose.

Adding Flair: Turns, Pace Changes, and The Automatic Sit

A good dance isn’t just walking in a straight line; it’s responsive and dynamic.

To build a dog that was truly attuned to my body language, we incorporated variations:

• Turns: Initially, I always turned into Leo. This simple move makes it impossible for the dog to ignore your change in direction and teaches them to pay close attention to your body to avoid a gentle bump.²³ Once he was watching me closely, we could practice turns away from him.
• Pace Changes: I would randomly speed up for a few steps and then slow to a crawl. This taught Leo to watch my rhythm and match it, rather than assuming a single, monotonous pace.⁴
• The Halt (Automatic Sit): Every time I stopped walking, I would cue a sit. Soon, he began to offer it automatically. This gives a clean, crisp end to a “dance phrase” and is an excellent way to reinforce focus and impulse control when you need to pause at a curb or in a crowd.²⁵

Even with the best choreography, missteps happen.

The key is to see them not as failures, but as communication breakdowns that need clarification.

The Problem (What You See)	The “Dance” Diagnosis (What It Means)	The Solution (How to Reconnect)
Forging (Pulling Ahead)	Rushing the tempo; anticipating the next move instead of waiting for your lead.	Practice unpredictable stop-and-start exercises. Take one step, stop, reward in position. Take two steps, stop, reward. Make frequent, abrupt turns into the dog to reset focus back on you.8 Ensure your reward is not being delivered from in front of you.26
Lagging (Falling Behind)	Falling behind the beat; may indicate confusion, fatigue, or low motivation.	Increase your rate of reinforcement. Use a higher-value treat. Make your praise more exciting and energetic. Keep sessions short and end on a positive note. Ensure the environment isn’t too scary or overwhelming.30
Crabbing (Rear End Swings Out)	Not following your lead; poor body awareness.	Go back to foundation work. Practice with a wall or barrier on the dog’s side to guide them into a straight line.25 Use pivot-dish exercises to increase rear-end awareness.19
Sniffing/Losing Focus	Distracted from the dance partner; the environment is more interesting than you are.	Increase your value. Practice in lower-distraction areas first. Use the heel as a specific, short-duration “game” with a clear release, rather than expecting constant focus for the whole walk.33

Chapter 5: Taking the Show on the Road – The Dance in the Real World

The true test of any training is how it holds up outside the sterile environment of your living room.

This final phase was about taking our dance into the real world, understanding its practical purpose, and knowing when the music should stop.

The Heel as a Management Tool: Navigating the Crowded Ballroom

The focused “dance” of heeling is far more than a party trick; it’s one of the most powerful management tools a dog owner can possess.

For Leo and me, this was the ultimate game-changer.

That intense focus we built became our superpower for navigating real-world challenges.

When we saw another dog approaching—once a trigger for frantic pulling—I could now say “Heel!” in an upbeat voice.

It became a cue to start our dance.

Leo’s focus would snap from the other dog to me, and we would move past the distraction together, a connected team.

This is a common and transformative experience for owners of reactive dogs; the heel provides a positive, incompatible behavior that replaces anxiety and lunging with focus and connection.²⁹

Crossing a busy street, navigating a crowded farmer’s market, or squeezing past people on a narrow trail—these were no longer sources of stress, but opportunities to perform our short, focused dance.

Knowing When to Rest: The “Sniffari” Intermission

Perhaps the most critical lesson of all was this: a dog cannot, and should not, be expected to “dance” for an entire 30-minute walk.

This unrealistic expectation is a primary source of failure and frustration for both dog and owner.

A walk must also be for the dog’s enrichment.

This led us to embrace the concept of two distinct types of walking.

To make this work, a clear release cue is essential.

A word like “Free!” or “Okay!” signals to the dog that the focused dance is over and they are now free to be a dog—to sniff, to explore, and to process the world through their nose.²

Our walks became a blend of both modes.

We would “dance” (heel) across intersections or past distractions, and then I would release him for a “sniffari” in the park, allowing him the crucial mental enrichment that sniffing provides.³³

This balance respects the dog’s needs while providing the handler with control when it matters most.

To avoid confusion, it’s vital for every owner to understand the difference between these two walking modes.

	Formal Heel (The Dance)	Loose-Leash Walk (The Sniffari)
Purpose	Precision, focus, management, safety	Enrichment, exercise, exploration
Dog’s Position	Shoulder aligned with handler’s leg 37	In a zone around the handler, not pulling
Dog’s Focus	On the handler 29	On the environment
Leash State	Loose, J-shape	Loose, but not necessarily a J-shape
Handler’s Role	Active “dance partner,” giving cues	“Seatbelt” supervisor, ensuring safety 38
When to Use	Crossing streets, passing distractions, navigating crowds, short durations 39	Parks, quiet trails, the majority of a relaxed walk 33

Conclusion: The Silent Conversation

Today, when Leo and I walk, the leash is different.

It hangs in a loose, gentle curve between us.

It’s no longer a tool of conflict, a rope in a tug-of-war.

It’s a light, sensitive line of communication, like the joined hands of dance partners, conveying subtle shifts in direction and pace.

Our walk is a silent conversation.

The journey to a perfect heel was never about finding the right technique or the magic collar.

It was about building the right relationship.

It was about me learning to lead with clarity and joy, and Leo learning to trust that following my lead was the most rewarding thing he could do.

The heel is our moving meditation, a shared state of focus that strengthens our bond with every step.

The ultimate reward isn’t a dog that obeys my command, but a partner who, when I ask, joyfully chooses to dance with me.

Works cited

1. Positive Reinforcement Dog Training: The Science Behind Operant Conditioning, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/training/operant-conditioning-positive-reinforcement-dog-training/
2. Teach Your Puppy These 5 Basic Cues – American Kennel Club, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/training/teach-your-puppy-these-5-basic-commands/
3. DOG TRAINING METHODS PROS AND CONS, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.waggingrightsdogtraining.com/dog-training-methods-pros-and-cons
4. Why Your Dog Struggles With The ‘Heel’ Command—And How To Fix It | Off Leash K9 Training Of Sterling, accessed August 11, 2025, https://sterlingdogtrainers.com/why-your-dog-struggles-with-the-heel-command-and-how-to-fix-it/
5. How to Choose the Perfect Dog Training Method for Your Pup, accessed August 11, 2025, https://nateschoemer.com/how-to-choose-the-perfect-dog-training-method-for-your-pup/
6. Motivation problems in the heeling exercise | Blog by K9 Pro and Steve Courtney Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, http://blog.k9pro.com.au/motivation-problems-in-the-heeling-exercise/
7. Transcript of Episode 177: Dog Training Outside The Box: Transfer Of Value Case Study – Susan Garrett, accessed August 11, 2025, https://dogsthat.com/transcript/episode-177/
8. How can I teach my dog that “heel” is a constant state of being rather than a check-in?, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/9si0pe/how_can_i_teach_my_dog_that_heel_is_a_constant/
9. Positive Reinforcement vs Balanced Dog Training – PetsTEK, accessed August 11, 2025, https://petstek.com/blogs/petstek-blog/positive-reinforcement-vs-balanced-dog-training
10. Dog Training Philosophy | Tools & Methods, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.flashdogtraining.com/our-philosophy/
11. In Defense of Balanced Dog Training – Nitro K-9 LLC, accessed August 11, 2025, https://nitrocanine.com/in-defense-of-balanced-training/
12. Heel / Whoa – Gun Dog Forum, accessed August 11, 2025, http://gundogforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=3758
13. Teaching a Dancing Dog | Dancing with Your Dog | PetMD, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.petmd.com/dog/wellness/evr_dg_dancing_with_your_dog
14. Step Your Way Into The World Of Musical Freestyle A.K.A “Dog Dancing” – American Kennel Club, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/lifestyle/welcome-to-the-world-of-musical-freestyle-dog-dancing/
15. Heelwork to Music Competition Part Two | Crufts 2025 – YouTube, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYO0DQaW6OQ
16. What is Dog Dancing? An Intro To Freestyle Heelwork To Music – Whole Dog Journal, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/lifestyle/what-is-dog-dancing-an-intro-to-freestyle-heelwork-to-music/
17. Getting Started with Heelwork to Music in Nottingham – Briar Dunn Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.briardunndogtraining.co.uk/blog/blog-post-title-three-n43at
18. Rally Obedience | Positively.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://positively.com/dog-training/article/dogs-sports-activities-rally-obedience
19. Pivoting to Lovely Heeling – 2 Cool Border Collies + 1, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.2coolbcs.com/positive-heelwork—pivoting.html
20. The Power Of Relationship-Based Dog Training, accessed August 11, 2025, https://dogadventuresnw.com/the-power-of-relationship-based-dog-training/
21. Dog Training Is About Teamwork – So Much PETential, accessed August 11, 2025, https://somuchpetential.com/dog-training-is-about-teamwork/
22. Benefits of Relationship Based Dog Training – Maryville/Alcoa Animal Rescue Center, accessed August 11, 2025, https://maarcadopt.org/benefits-of-relationship-based-dog-training/
23. A Simplified Approach to Heeling How to teach an essential skill that every bird dog should have. – Pheasants Forever, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.pheasantsforever.org/BlogLanding/Blogs/Pheasants-Forever/A-Simplified-Approach-to-Heeling.aspx
24. Teaching foster dog where the heel position is – YouTube, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jIa9lEvKNuE
25. Teaching dog to come to heel position : r/Dogtraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/6jgjz6/teaching_dog_to_come_to_heel_position/
26. How to Teach Your Dog to Heel – Project Upland, accessed August 11, 2025, https://projectupland.com/hunting-dogs/teaching-your-dog-to-heel/
27. Leerburg On Demand | Push Heeling with Janice Gunn, accessed August 11, 2025, https://leerburg.com/flix/player.php/1805/Push_Heeling_with_Janice_Gunn
28. Dog Training: Teaching Left Turns for Your Dog – TikTok, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.tiktok.com/@kaizen.canine/video/7198309871127760174
29. Teaching “heel” has helped so much on walks : r/Dogtraining – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/t0gfhn/teaching_heel_has_helped_so_much_on_walks/
30. Heeling | Positively.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://positively.com/dog-training/article/canine-life-skills-heeling
31. Walking to heel – Gundog Training Forum, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.gundogtrainingforum.co.uk/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=430
32. How to teach Competition Heeling! Easy Guide! – YouTube, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kltH2LhMwpE&pp=0gcJCfwAo7VqN5tD
33. What’s the Deal with Heel? – Thriving Canine, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.thrivingcanine.com/blog/whats-deal-heel/
34. The Healing POWER Of Heel For Your Dog – Nitro K-9 LLC, accessed August 11, 2025, https://nitrocanine.com/proper-dog-heeling/
35. You asked for it, so here it is: How to train your dog to heel like Delta! (with step-by-step instructions) – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/fukw0o/you_asked_for_it_so_here_it_is_how_to_train_your/
36. Why I DON’T Train My Clients’ Dogs to Heel – 4Knines, accessed August 11, 2025, https://4knines.com/blogs/4knines-blog-home-page/why-i-don-t-train-my-client-s-dogs-to-heel
37. Defining “Perfect” Heel Position – Fenzi Dog Sports Academy, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.fenzidogsportsacademy.com/blog/defining-perfect-heel-position
38. Amazing Analogies To Support Your Dog • Your Happy Dog Coach, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.yourhappydogcoach.ca/amazing-analogies/
39. is it absolutely necessary for my dog to heel beside me or behind me? – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/udpmui/is_it_absolutely_necessary_for_my_dog_to_heel/