From Shock Collars to Silent Signals: How I Unlocked a New Way to Communicate with My Hunting Dog

For twenty years, the feel of a shotgun in my hands and the sight of a good dog working a field have been the constants in my life.

As a gundog trainer, I’ve always believed in the classic methods: a firm voice, a sharp whistle, and an unbreakable bond built on thousands of hours of patient repetition.

I viewed electronic collars with the same disdain many do—as a shortcut, a crude tool for those lacking patience or skill.

I’d heard all the horror stories and read the arguments against them, and they resonated with my own philosophy of partnership.¹

They were “shock collars,” plain and simple, and I wanted no part of them.

Then came Gus.

He was a German Shorthaired Pointer with more natural talent in his paws than any dog I’d ever trained.

He was brilliant, driven, and what we in the business call “soft”—sensitive and eager to please.

On leash and in the yard, he was a prodigy.

But the moment his paws hit the open field, a switch flipped.

The symphony of scents, the rustle of unseen birds, the sheer, intoxicating freedom—it was too much.

My voice, my whistle, even the physical check cord became irrelevant noise in the face of his primal instincts.⁴

Our communication line, so clear and strong in a controlled setting, went completely dead.

The failure that shattered my convictions came on a crisp autumn afternoon.

Gus locked onto the scent of a running pheasant, and he was gone.

He ignored my increasingly frantic “Here!” commands, blew past my whistle blasts, and charged headlong across a property line toward a rural highway I knew was just beyond the tree line.

In that moment, standing helpless as the dog I loved and had poured my life into vanished from my control, I felt a professional and personal powerlessness that was utterly gut-wrenching.

My methods, the ones I had trusted for two decades, had failed when it mattered most.³

I had no way to get his attention, no way to keep him safe.

That night, I knew I had to find a better way to speak to my dog across the noise of the hunt.

The Epiphany: From Static Shock to Haptic Signal

My search for an answer led me down a surprising path, away from the familiar world of dog training and into the seemingly unrelated fields of human-computer interaction and assistive technology.

I wasn’t looking for a better disciplinary tool; I was looking for a better communication channel.

And that’s when I found it: the concept of haptic technology.

Haptics, I learned, is the science of communicating through touch.⁸

It’s not about a simple, jarring buzz like an old pager.

It’s a rich, nuanced language of vibrations, forces, and motions designed to convey complex information.

Think of the difference between an old video game controller that just rumbled indiscriminately and a modern one that lets you feel the subtle texture of different surfaces or the tension of a bowstring.⁸

That is the leap from a simple alert to a true communication system.

What struck me was where this technology was being used.

It wasn’t for punishment.

It was for critical, life-saving communication in environments where visual and auditory cues were insufficient.

Pilots in WWII-era aircraft used haptic feedback in their control columns to feel an approaching engine stall, giving them crucial information their instruments couldn’t.¹⁰

Modern surgeons use haptic feedback to

feel tissue resistance through robotic instruments, allowing for precision from miles away.¹⁰

And most profoundly, haptic systems are used to provide rich, detailed environmental information to deaf-blind individuals, describing the layout of a room or the emotion on a person’s face through a standardized language of touch on their back.¹²

This was my epiphany.

What if the modern e-collar wasn’t a “shock collar” at all? What if it was a haptic communication device for a dog? What if the goal wasn’t to punish a mistake, but to send a clear, non-verbal, tactile message across a noisy field—a “tap on the shoulder” to say, “Hey, listen to me”? This completely reframed the problem.

The challenge wasn’t a lack of enforcement; it was a failure of communication.¹³

The debate I’d been hearing for years was based on a fundamental category error.

Both proponents and opponents were arguing about the merits of a disciplinary tool, when the technology had evolved into a communication interface.

It was like arguing about whether a smartphone is a good or bad flashlight, completely missing its primary function.

The Great Debate Deconstructed: The Punishment Model vs. The Haptic Communication Model

To move forward, it’s essential to address the intense controversy surrounding these tools.

The arguments against them, particularly from respected bodies like the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), are serious and valid—when applied to an outdated model of use.

These organizations rightly point out that training methods based on fear and pain can cause significant psychological distress, including anxiety and aggression, and can damage the human-animal bond.¹⁶

They argue, based on scientific studies, that there is no evidence aversive methods are necessary or more effective than reward-based training.¹

These criticisms are entirely correct when aimed at what I call the Punishment Model.

This is the “slap it on and zap it” approach, where the collar is used as a remote-controlled punisher to stop unwanted behavior.

It is this very model that gives the tool its “shock collar” reputation and rightfully draws condemnation.

But the haptic paradigm reveals a second, entirely different approach: the Haptic Communication Model.

This modern, ethical framework uses the collar not to punish, but to open a clear line of communication.

It uses the lowest possible sensation to get the dog’s attention and guide it toward a known behavior, a process the dog learns to control.

The distinction between these two models is not subtle; it is the difference between shouting at someone in anger and tapping them on the shoulder to ask a question.

The following table breaks down the fundamental differences between these two opposing methodologies.

It is designed to validate the legitimate concerns of skeptics while presenting a clear, structured, and humane alternative.

Feature	Punishment Model (“Shock Collar”)	Haptic Communication Model (“E-Collar”)
Primary Goal	Stop an unwanted behavior through aversion.	Open a line of communication to guide behavior.
Mechanism	Positive Punishment (Adding a painful or startling stimulus to decrease a behavior).19	Negative Reinforcement (Removing a mild sensation when the correct behavior is performed).20
Timing of Use	After the dog makes a mistake, as a consequence.	During a command to cue attention, like an invisible leash.
Stimulation Level	High enough to be punitive and startling, intended to stop a behavior in its tracks.	The lowest level the dog can perceive (the “working level” or “whisper”).2
Dog’s Experience	Confusion, fear, pain, stress, and potential association of pain with the handler or environment.1	Clarity, focus, and a sense of control, as the dog learns how to “turn off” the sensation.14
Prerequisites	Often none; the collar is used as a “quick fix” without foundational training.24	The dog must already be fluent in the command on a leash before the collar is introduced.25
Outcome	Temporary suppression of behavior, with high risk of creating fear, anxiety, or aggression.17	Reliable off-leash performance and a stronger, more trusting partnership with the handler.15

The Vocabulary of Touch: A Hunter’s Guide to Choosing Your Communication Device

Viewing the e-collar through the haptic lens transforms the selection process.

You are no longer just buying a “collar”; you are choosing a communication device with a specific “haptic vocabulary” tailored to the conversations you need to have with your dog in the field.

Core Technological Principles

Modern, high-quality e-collars are technological marvels compared to their crude predecessors.

The most significant leap is the move from a simple, sharp “shock” to a more nuanced “stimulation.” Reputable brands use a wide-pulse stimulation, similar to a TENS (Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation) unit used in physical therapy, which stimulates the neck muscles rather than just delivering a painful jolt.²⁸

This is a critical distinction that debunks myths about the collars “burning” a dog’s skin; such injuries are almost always pressure sores from a collar left on too long or fitted improperly, not electrical burns.³¹

This technology provides a rich vocabulary for communication:

• Static Stimulation: This is the primary “voice” of the collar. With up to 127 distinct levels on some models, it allows for incredible nuance. You can deliver a “whisper” at level 5 to get your dog’s attention in the yard, or a “shout” at a higher level to cut through the adrenaline of a chase in a safety-critical moment.³²
• Vibration (HPP – High Performance Pager): This is a different dialect. It’s a strong, non-static vibration that can be used as an alternative attention-getter. For some dogs, it’s a perfect cue, while others may find it more startling than a very low-level static stimulation.¹⁴
• Tone/Beep: This acts as a marker or a pre-cue. It can be conditioned to mean “good job,” much like a clicker, or to mean “hey, pay attention, a command is coming”.²⁵

Key Features for the Hunter’s Conversational Context

Your hunting style dictates the features you need.

• Range: How far does your conversation need to travel? Range is measured in “line of sight,” meaning on flat, open ground.³³ Hills, dense woods, and water will reduce effective range. An upland hunter with a big-running pointer needs a system with a 1-mile or greater range, while a waterfowl hunter whose retriever is working within a few hundred yards can use a 1/2-mile system effectively.²⁵
• Waterproofing (e.g., DryTek®): For the duck blind or any hunt in foul weather, this is non-negotiable. A system must be fully waterproof and submersible to be reliable for a serious gundog.²⁵
• GPS Tracking: This is the ultimate evolution in handler-dog communication, allowing you to “see” your dog’s location, speed, and status (running or on-point) in dense cover. It provides an unparalleled layer of safety and information.³²
• Beeper/Locator: This is a vital feature for upland hunters. When a dog goes on point in thick brush, the beeper allows the handler to locate them quickly and safely.³²
• Multi-Dog Systems: For handlers running more than one dog, these systems allow you to manage conversations with each dog from a single remote, toggling between them seamlessly.³²

Hunting Dog E-Collar Feature Comparison

This table translates technical specifications into a practical buyer’s guide, helping you choose the best tool for your specific hunting discipline.

Feature	Upland Hunter (e.g., Pointers, Setters)	Waterfowl Hunter (e.g., Retrievers)	All-Around / Yard Trainer
Primary Need	Long-range control & locating a dog on point.	Absolute waterproofing & close/mid-range control.	Versatility for obedience and occasional field use.
Recommended Range	1 Mile or more.25	1/2 to 3/4 Mile.33	1/2 Mile.25
Key Feature	Integrated Beeper/Locator or GPS with “on point” alerts.32	DryTek® (or equivalent) waterproofing; camouflage pattern is a plus.25	Multiple stimulation types (Tone, Vibrate, Static); customizable levels.25
Example Model(s)	SportDOG® UplandHunter® 1875, Dogtra T&B DUAL	SportDOG® WetlandHunter® 1825X, Garmin Sport PRO	SportDOG® FieldTrainer® 425X, E-Collar Technologies ME-300

The Grammar of Haptics: A Step-by-Step Guide to Collar Conditioning

This is where the paradigm shift becomes practice.

Conditioning is the process of teaching your dog the “grammar” of haptic communication.

Done correctly, it’s a logical, gentle, and clear process that builds confidence and reliability.

The Foundational Rule: Prerequisites First!

This cannot be overstated: an e-collar reinforces known commands; it does not teach them.²⁵

Before the collar is ever turned on, your dog must be 100% fluent with basic commands like “Here,” “Sit,” and “Kennel” using a leash and positive reinforcement.

Attempting to use the collar to teach a command from scratch is the single biggest mistake a handler can make, leading to fear and confusion.²⁴

Step 1: Acclimation & Association (Creating Neutrality)

The first goal is to ensure the dog has no negative (or positive) association with the collar itself.

• Action: Have your dog wear the collar, turned off, for at least a week or two. Put it on during meal times, before walks, during play—any time the dog is having a good experience.²⁵
• Goal: To prevent “collar wiseness,” where the dog only behaves when the hardware is on.²⁴ The collar should become as neutral and normal as their everyday flat collar.

Step 2: Finding the “Whisper” (Calibrating the Volume)

This is the most crucial step for humane and effective use.

You must find your dog’s lowest perceptible stimulation level, also known as their “working level”.²²

• Action: In a quiet, distraction-free area, with the collar fitted snugly, set the remote to its lowest level (Level 1). Tap the continuous stimulation button briefly. Watch your dog intently for any subtle sign of recognition: an ear twitch, a head tilt, a slight change in expression, or looking down as if a fly landed on them.²² If you see no reaction, move to Level 2 and repeat.
• Goal: To find the absolute minimum level that gets a flicker of attention. This is your “haptic whisper.” If the dog yelps, panics, or scratches frantically, the level is far too high.²² This process establishes that the communication is meant to be a subtle cue, not a painful correction.

Step 3: Teaching the Core Principle – “Pressure On, Pressure Off”

This is the fundamental grammatical rule of haptic communication.

The dog learns that their compliance turns off the sensation.²⁰

• The “Here” Command Example (with a 30-foot long line):

1. With the dog on the long line, give your verbal command, “Here.”
2. Simultaneously, press and hold the continuous stimulation button at their “whisper” level AND apply light, steady pressure with the long line.
3. The instant the dog turns and takes a step toward you, release the stimulation button and the leash pressure completely. The release is their reward.
4. When the dog reaches you, shower them with praise and a high-value treat.³⁶

• The Dog’s Learning: The dog makes a powerful connection: “I feel a weird tap, I hear ‘Here,’ and when I move toward my handler, the tapping stops and I get a reward.” They learn they are in complete control of the sensation. This is a clear, unemotional feedback loop, fundamentally different from punishment.²¹

Step 4: Layering with Positive Reinforcement (Making the Conversation Rewarding)

While the release of pressure is inherently reinforcing, actively layering in positive rewards is what builds a joyful, willing partner.

• Action: Every time the dog responds correctly, follow up with enthusiastic praise, a favorite toy, or a high-value treat.¹³
• Goal: To create a dog that is not just complying to avoid a sensation, but is actively happy to participate in the “conversation.” Many properly conditioned dogs will get visibly excited when the e-collar comes out, because they associate it with the fun, engagement, and rewards of working with their handler.¹⁴

Fluent Conversations: Advanced Applications and Troubleshooting

Once your dog understands the basic grammar, you can begin to have more complex conversations in the field.

This means applying the same principles to achieve reliable performance amidst the high-distraction environment of a hunt.

Advanced Field Applications

• Enforcing Steadiness: For a pointing dog that starts to “creep” on a bird, a low-level haptic cue paired with the “Whoa” command can reinforce the stop, preventing a flushed bird and a lost opportunity.⁴⁵
• Remote Sit for Waterfowl: A quick haptic cue can be used to sit a retriever at a distance, keeping them steady in the blind or on the bank.
• “Trash” Breaking for Safety: This is one of the most critical uses. When a dog gives chase to a non-game animal like a deer or porcupine, a higher-level, non-negotiable haptic correction can be a lifesaver. This is not for training obedience but for breaking a dangerous, instinct-driven fixation that could lead the dog into traffic or a painful encounter.⁶

Troubleshooting Common “Communication Breakdowns”

When training stalls, it’s rarely because the dog is “stubborn.” It’s almost always a breakdown in communication.

By applying the haptic model, we can diagnose and solve these issues logically.

Communication Breakdown (The Problem)	The Outdated Interpretation	The Haptic Diagnosis & Solution
Dog yelps or panics at stimulation.	“This dog is too soft for an e-collar.”	Diagnosis: The “volume” is too loud. You’ve skipped or rushed finding the “whisper” level. Solution: Immediately lower the level. Go back to a quiet environment and re-do the “Finding the Whisper” exercise from Step 2.22
Dog only listens when the collar is on.	“He’s being defiant and testing me.”	Diagnosis: “Collar Wiseness.” The dog incorrectly associates the cue with the hardware, not the command. Solution: Go back to Step 1. Have the dog wear the collar (turned off) constantly during all positive activities for a week or two to neutralize it.24
Dog runs to handler when cued for a different command (e.g., “Sit”).	“The dog is confused and doesn’t get it.”	Diagnosis: Poor “grammar.” The dog has only learned one meaning for the haptic cue: “come here.” Solution: Isolate commands. Dedicate training sessions to a single new command until it’s fluent before adding another.37
Inconsistent response in the field.	“This collar is a piece of junk.”	Diagnosis: Poor signal transmission. The message isn’t getting through clearly. Solution: Check collar fit. It must be snug (two fingers underneath) with the contact points touching the skin. Use longer contact points for dogs with thick fur. A loose collar is like a bad cell signal.28
Dog ignores low-level stim during high excitement (e.g., chasing a bird).	“I have to punish him to make him listen.”	Diagnosis: The “whisper” is being drowned out by environmental “noise” (adrenaline, prey drive). Solution: The haptic model allows for contextually raising the volume. A slightly higher, but still fair, level is needed to cut through the distraction. This is adjusting for the environment, not punishing.33

A Partnership Built on Clarity, Trust, and Safety

Returning to my story with Gus, the haptic communication model changed everything.

We went through the conditioning process step-by-step, teaching him that the gentle tap on his neck was my voice, reaching out to him when my own couldn’t.

He learned he could turn that tap off simply by listening to the “Here” command he already knew so well.

There was no fear, no panic—just clarity.

The result was a transformation.

Gus became the confident, reliable partner in the field I always knew he could be.

Our bond, once frayed by my frustration and his confusion, deepened into one of mutual trust.

I trusted him with more freedom, and he trusted me to guide him safely.

The e-collar is not inherently good or evil; it is a powerful amplifier.

When used within the archaic Punishment Model, it amplifies fear, pain, and confusion.

But when used within the modern Haptic Communication Model, it amplifies clarity, trust, and the incredible partnership between a handler and their dog.

By embracing this new paradigm, we can move beyond the “shock collar” debate and unlock a level of communication, performance, and safety we never thought possible.

We can enjoy the hunt more fully, and most importantly, we can ensure our best friend comes home safely every single time.⁷

Works cited

1. The Shocking Truth About Shock Collars – Three Oaks Animal Behavior Counseling, accessed August 13, 2025, https://animalbehaviorok.com/shocking-truth-about-shock-collars/
2. The Most Controversial Tool in Dog Training – Pack Leader Dogs, accessed August 13, 2025, https://packleaderdogs.com/the-most-controversial-tool-in-dog-training/
3. Why I chose to use an e collar and my experience / results : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/1ace1cb/why_i_chose_to_use_an_e_collar_and_my_experience/
4. How to Avoid Common Puppy Training Problems – Gun Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.gundogmag.com/editorial/how-to-avoid-common-puppy-training-problems/460731
5. Predatory Behaviors In Pet Dogs – Aggressive Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://aggressivedog.com/2024/05/06/predatory-behaviors-in-pet-dogs/
6. HOW AN ECOLLAR SAVED MY DOG’S LIFE – Be The Boss Dog Training, accessed August 13, 2025, https://bethebossdogtraining.com/how-an-ecollar-saved-my-dogs-life/
7. Importance of eCollars? | Ultimate Pheasant Hunting Forums, accessed August 13, 2025, https://forum.ultimatepheasanthunting.com/threads/importance-of-ecollars.27078/
8. Haptic technology – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haptic_technology
9. Introduction To Haptic Feedback – Precision Microdrives, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.precisionmicrodrives.com/introduction-to-haptic-feedback
10. What Is Haptic Feedback? (2025) | DesignRush, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.designrush.com/agency/ui-ux-design/trends/haptic-feedback
11. Haptic technology | Definition, History, Examples, & Industry …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/technology/haptic-technology
12. Haptic Communication to Facilitate Braille Instruction for DeafBlind …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.helenkeller.org/resources/haptic-communication-facilitate-braille-instruction-deafblind-adults/
13. E-Collar for Dogs: What It Is and How It Works – Halo Collar Blog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.halocollar.com/blog/dog-training/e-collar-for-dogs-what-it-is-and-how-it-works/
14. Why is an ecollar not abusive? : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/1kaptap/why_is_an_ecollar_not_abusive/
15. Dog e-collar training: a case for clarity and another life saved. – Robin MacFarlane, accessed August 13, 2025, https://robinmacfarlane.com/dog-e-collar-training-a-case-for-clarity-and-another-life-saved/
16. 5 Reasons not to use a shock collar – BC SPCA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://spca.bc.ca/ways-to-help/take-action/animals-in-the-home/the-shocking-truth-about-electronic-collars/5-reasons-not-to-use-a-shock-collar/
17. Position Statement on Humane Dog Training – The American …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://avsab.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/AVSAB-Humane-Dog-Training-Position-Statement-2021.pdf
18. Shock Collars in Dog Training (E-Collars & Remote Systems) – Alana Stevenson, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.alanastevenson.com/shock-collars-dog-training/
19. The Electric Collar Debate – Working Trials Info, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.workingtrials.info/society-information/training-articles/334-general-dog-training/936-the-electric-collar-debate
20. How to Properly Introduce Your Bird Dog to an E-Collar – Pheasants …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.pheasantsforever.org/BlogLanding/Blogs/Field-Notes/How-to-Properly-Introduce-Your-Bird-Dog-to-an-E-Co.aspx?feed=articles
21. Leerburg Webboard | Vibration collar as conditioned punisher?, accessed August 13, 2025, https://leerburg.com/webboard/thread.php?topic_id=34895
22. Finding Your Dog’s “Just Right” E‑Collar Level – SportDOG, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.sportdog.com/hunting-training-tips/finding-your-dogs-just-right-e-collar-level
23. E COLLAR 101 – Wagging Rights Dog Training, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.waggingrightsdogtraining.com/e-collar-101
24. E-COLLAR: Top 7 Mistakes – Thriving Canine, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.thrivingcanine.com/blog/e-collar-top-7-mistakes/
25. The Ultimate SportDOG Guide: Choosing the Best E-Collar for Your Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.sportdog.com/hunting-training-tips/the-ultimate-sportdog-guide-to-choosing-the-best-e-collar-for-your-dog
26. First time with shock collar | Ultimate Pheasant Hunting Forums, accessed August 13, 2025, https://forum.ultimatepheasanthunting.com/threads/first-time-with-shock-collar.24730/
27. Feeling nervous! Your e-collar success stories, please! : r/OpenDogTraining – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenDogTraining/comments/cc2cbw/feeling_nervous_your_ecollar_success_stories/
28. 32 Tips For Choosing and Using Modern E-Collars – Gun Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.gundogmag.com/editorial/collar_tips/175361
29. The Ultimate Trainer’s Guide on an E-Collar for Dogs – Ray Allen Manufacturing, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.rayallen.com/the-ultimate-guide-to-e-collar-for-dogs
30. E-Collar Technologies | Dog Training E-Collars, E-Fence, Barkless, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ecollar.com/
31. 9 E-Collar Training Myths: Busted – Long Haul Trekkers, accessed August 13, 2025, https://longhaultrekkers.com/e-collar-training-myths/
32. Understanding E-Collars: Purpose and Limitations – Gun Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.gundogmag.com/editorial/understanding-ecollars/376912
33. Choosing the Right E-Collar – Sport Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.sportdog.com/hunting-training-tips/choosing-the-right-e-collar
34. Top Hunting Dog Training Collars – Gun Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.gundogmag.com/editorial/top-dog-training-collars/461488
35. Introducing a Dog to an E-Collar – A Guide to Collar Conditioning – Project Upland, accessed August 13, 2025, https://projectupland.com/hunting-dogs/introducing-a-dog-to-an-e-collar-a-guide-to-collar-conditioning-2/
36. Introducing E-Collar | When and How to Use an E Collar for Training – Rob’s Dogs, accessed August 13, 2025, https://robsdogs.com/e-collar-education/
37. COLLAR CONDITIONING | Lone Duck, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.loneduckoutfitters.com/blogs/the-gun-dog-blog/collar-conditioning
38. Thinking of getting an eCollar? How to start out the right way – The Naked Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.thenakeddogtraining.com/traininghowtos/2020/2/18/thinking-of-getting-an-e-collar-how-to-start-out-the-right-way
39. www.ancillaryk9.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ancillaryk9.com/blog/e-collar-balanced-dog-training#:~:text=Using%20E%2DCollars%20Humanely%3A%20Setting%20the%20Correct%20Level&text=A%20well%2Dtrained%20handler%20will,the%20stimulation%20without%20experiencing%20discomfort.
40. petspy.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://petspy.com/blogs/dog-training/training-hunting-dog-with-an-e-collar#:~:text=For%20this%20to%20happen%2C%20you,to%20heap%20praises%20on%20him!
41. E Collar Training Steps For Beginners! – YouTube, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCDW12Q9etE
42. The Perfect Combination: E-Collar Training and Positive Reinforcement, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.invirox.com/blogs/dog-training-solutions/the-perfect-combination-e-collar-training-and-positive-reinforcement
43. E Collar Training: A Gentle Approach to Effective Communication with Your Dog, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.educatorcollars.com/blog/e-collar-training
44. E-collar training : r/pitbulls – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/pitbulls/comments/1825if4/ecollar_training/
45. Common Bird Dog Problems – Pheasants Forever, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.pheasantsforever.org/BlogLanding/Blogs/Nancy-Anisfield/Common-Bird-Dog-Problems.aspx?feed=articles
46. Top 7 Mistakes Every Dog Owner Must Avoid When Using an E-Collar, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.invirox.com/blogs/dog-training-solutions/top-7-mistakes-every-dog-owner-must-avoid-when-using-an-e-collar
47. How to Train a Dog on an E Collar! – YouTube, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YUBZ-kl5ic
48. How to Adjust E-Collar Stimulation Levels Based on Your Dog’s Sensitivity, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.educatorcollars.com/blog/how-to-use-an-adjustable-e-collar